Hotham gathered his prizes and dismasted ships and turned eastwards for the anchorage in the
Gulf of La Spezia. All of his battle line had been in action and taken casualties, with the heaviest losses aboard the badly damaged and partially dismasted
Illustrious and
Courageux.
Captain,
Bedford,
Egmont and
HMS Windsor Castle were also damaged, all suffering more than 20 casualties. The ship's jury masts were lost overboard and the many holes in the hull allowed water to pour into the ship. At 13:30 the ship's situation was worsened when a loaded cannon fired accidentally, blowing off the gunport and blasting a large hole in the ship from the inside. This rendered
Illustrious unmanageable, and by 14:00 the Italian coast was clearly visible to the east. His ship drifting dangerously inshore, at 14:30 Captain
Thomas Frederick gave control to a sailor on board who claimed to have navigated the region and knew a safe anchorage. The following morning
Tarleton came alongside the irreparably damaged
Illustrious, although it was not until 20 March that the weather had abated sufficiently to permit the evacuation to begin.
Tarleton,
Lowestoft,
HMS Romulus, and teams of
ship's boats, successfully removed all of the crew and most of the ship's stores without casualties. Once the wreck had been cleared, it was set on fire and abandoned. The surviving fleet remained at La Spezia for a week effecting basic repairs, before sailing for San Fiorenzo on 25 March. Refits lasted until 18 April, at which point Hotham returned to Leghorn.
Ça Ira survived only a little longer, catching fire accidentally while at anchor off San Fiorenzo on 11 April 1796 and being completely destroyed, although only four of the 600 crew were killed. Martin retreated to Hyères after the battle, joined shortly afterwards by the damaged ships from Gourjean Bay and the flagship from Genoa. The captains of
Sans Culottes,
Mercure and
Duquesne were reprimanded by Martin for failing to follow his orders, but subsequently cleared of misconduct by a jury, which also highly commended the captains of
Ça Ira and
Censeur. He did not sail again until June, and was caught by Hotham once more in early July. Retreating towards Hyères, the French fleet was pursued by the British, and the rearmost ship
Alcide was overrun and destroyed at the
Battle of the Hyères Islands. Although the battle was a British victory, Nelson was privately scathing of Hotham's refusal to renew the action, writing that "I could never have called it well
done". Hotham believed his actions vindicated by the prevention of possible French landings on Corsica and was preoccupied by events on land, where a peace treaty between France and Tuscany placed access to the harbour at Leghorn in jeopardy. Historians have criticised Hotham's timidity,
William Laird Clowes writing in 1900 stated that "it was an unsatisfactory victory. Hotham took two ships of the line but gained little credit, seeing that he might have, and should have, done much more." More than five decades after the battle the
Admiralty recognised the action with a clasp attached to the
Naval General Service Medal, awarded upon application to all British participants still living in 1847. ==Notes==