NMEs Crystal Bell commended "New Woman" as a "sleek, pulsating celebration of reinvention" and
Alter Egos "standout moment", showing the "electrifying" results when Lisa "locks into a sound and a statement" on the album. Bell also praised the music video as it "amplifies the song's allure" with its depiction of Lisa as a "force of nature". In its review,
Screen Rant singled out "New Woman" as the "strongest" track of the album due to its "presenting both women in their own light with the juxtaposition of their verses coming together beautifully in the last chorus." Likewise,
The Skinnys Rhys Morgan celebrated the "drumtight laidback Max Martin production" as well as Rosalía's "sharp" cameo for "adding some friction and bite." Robin Murray of
Clash described the track as a "a real statement of feminine pop energy".
Pitchfork Joshua Minsoo Kim noted that hearing Rosalía "glide in Spanish" made it "glaringly obvious" that Lisa should have explored different languages on the album such as Thai. However, Ed Power of
The Irish Times derided the song as a "chemistry-lacking collaboration" that "sits in a state of inert indifference."
Rolling Stone declared "New Woman" the 70th best song of 2024 and opined that it "bangs in a late-Nineties teen-pop mode", praising the "none-more-Swedish beats" for recalling the
MTV Total Request Live era and the music video that "eroticizes flip phones and fax machines." Similarly,
NME named the song the 24th best K-pop song of 2024 and stated that Lisa came "guns blazing" and that all parts of the track effortlessly combine into "one of the most intoxicating fares of the year." They lauded the "artful airiness of the pre-chorus" that "flexes Lisa’s vocal chops" in a way that YG Entertainment underused, as well as Rosalía's "charismatic" feature. On the other hand,
Varietys Thania Garcia called it one of the worst songs of 2024 and described it as a "collaboration that sounds great in theory, but fails in practice." She praised Lisa and Rosalía individually as "exceptional vocalist[s]" and "virtuosos" but felt that the song was "disjointed" as if the artists recorded their parts separately. ==Accolades==