"During the war years and into the 1950s," Judith E. Stein writes, "the general public was to remain highly suspicious of abstraction, which many considered un-American. While the
art critic Clement Greenberg successfully challenged the public's negative response to abstraction, his attempt to communicate to the New York figurative painters of the fifties was less successful." A conversation recollected by Thomas B. Hess emphasized the perceived power of the critic:"It is impossible today to paint a face, pontificated the critic Clement Greenberg around 1950. "That's right," said de Kooning, "and it's impossible not to." In 1953, the journal
Reality was founded "to rise to the defense of any painter's right to paint any ways he wants." Backing this mission statement was an editorial committee that included
Isabel Bishop (1902–1988),
Edward Hopper (1882–1967),
Jack Levine (1915–2010),
Raphael Soyer (1899–1987) and
Henry Varnum Poor (1888–1970). The sculptor
Philip Pavia became "partisan publisher" of
It is. A Magazine for Abstract Art that he founded in 1958. In an open letter to Leslie Katz, the new publisher of
Arts Magazine, he wrote: "I am begging you to give the representational artist a better deal. The neglected representational and near-abstract artists, not the abstractionists, need a champion these days." Although none of these figurative advocates had the stature of critics like
Clement Greenberg or
Harold Rosenberg, they were recognized by critics as radicals, "represent[ing] a new generation to whom figurative art was in a sense more revolutionary than abstraction." The literary historian
Marjorie Perloff has made a convincing argument that
Frank O'Hara's poems on the works of Garace Hartigan and Larry Rivers proved "that he was really more at home with painting that retains at least some figuration than with pure abstraction." Frank O'Hara wrote an elegant defense in "Nature and New Painting," 1954, listing
Grace Hartigan (1922–2008),
Larry Rivers (1923–2002),
Elaine de Kooning (1918–1989),
Jane Freilicher (1924–),
Robert De Niro Sr. (1922–1993), Felix Pasilis (1922–),
Wolf Kahn (1927–) and
Marcia Marcus (1928–) as artists who responded to "the siren-like call of nature." O'Hara aligned the New York Figurative Expressionists within abstract expressionism, which had always taken a strong position against an implied protocol, "whether at the Metropolitan Museum or the Artists Club."
Thomas B. Hess wrote: "[T]he 'New figurative painting' which some have been expecting as a reaction against Abstract Expressionism was implicit in it at the start, and is one of its most lineal continuities." ==References==