Upon its release,
NHL 16 received positive reviews from critics and received much more positive reviews compared to its predecessor,
NHL 15, which received more mixed and average reviews from critics. On
GameRankings, the PlayStation 4 version holds a 79.67% rating, based on 23 reviews, and the Xbox One version holds an 82.23% rating, based on 15 reviews. On
Metacritic, the PlayStation 4 version holds a 78/100 rating, based on 28 reviews, and the Xbox One version holds an 80/100 rating, based on 18 reviews. Critics generally felt that
NHL 16 was an improvement over
NHL 15. They directed acclaim at the fun gameplay of the game's wide variety of game modes as well as the return of the EASHL mode. Some criticism was aimed mainly at some lack of depth in these game modes as well as the game's menus and interface. Mat Paget of
GameSpot awarded the game an 8/10. He complimented the content of
NHL 16s game modes as well as the inclusion of the On-Ice Trainer, which he believes would help brand new players and would work very well in the game's Be A Pro mode. He stated, however, that the game's menus can sometimes be confusing to get around. For
Game Informer, Matt Bertz wrote that EA Sports are heading in the right direction with
NHL 16, but he felt that they failed to bring any "game-breaking quality" in terms of gameplay. Bertz complimented the game's improved
artificial intelligence system for opposing teams as well as the
NHL on NBC game presentation. Anthony LaBella of
Game Revolution found the inclusion of several game modes to be positive for the game, but felt that some of them were not thoroughly developed enough. LaBella also enjoyed the revamped EASHL mode as well as the game's presentation. ==References==