On April 22, 2024, Mitchell was arrested at 4:45a.m. in
Detroit Lakes, Minnesota, by police who were responding to a burglary call. The following day she was charged with first-degree
burglary. According to the charging documents, she entered her stepmother's home in an attempt to steal several items. Mitchell stated that she was only interested in things that were of "sentimental value" to her, which included the ashes of her late father. Mitchell's stepmother disputed Mitchell's statement and said that she was fearful of Mitchell. Senate Democrats stripped Mitchell of committee assignments but did not express support for her resignation. State DFL chairman
Ken Martin stated that he would like her to resign by June 8, allowing her seat to be filled in a special election. Mitchell stated that she would not resign, and continued to vote in the 2024 legislative session. Mitchell was subjected to a Senate ethics inquiry on May 7. The committee declined to take any actions until after her court appearance on June 10. The following week, Republicans in the Minnesota State Senate introduced a motion to expel her, but the motion failed, with Mitchell providing the tie-breaking vote. In July 2025, Mitchell stood trial in
Becker County, where she was found guilty on charges of first-degree burglary and felony possession of burglary tools. In mid-2024, the Minnesotan news website
Alpha News sued the
Detroit Lakes Police Department to compel the release of the
body-worn camera footage of Mitchell's arrest. Becker County District Court Judge Gretchen D. Thilmony initially denied the request, citing the potential for the footage to prejudice the jury against Mitchell. In April 2025, the
Minnesota Court of Appeals reversed Thilmony's decision and
remanded the case, ordering the lower court to "apply a different balancing test". The prosecution then used the footage in its case against Mitchell, rendering it a
de facto public record, and it was released publicly shortly thereafter. The recording shows an "intruder dressed all in black beside [the victim's] bed" who was "[the victim's] stepdaughter, Nicole". When confronted by law enforcement officers, Mitchell surrendered peacefully and said she had done "something bad". On September 23, 2025, Becker County Judge Michael Fritz
sentenced Mitchell to 180 days in
county jail. Mitchell's defense team requested that the judge
stay the sentence until they could appeal it; Fritz declined, saying, "there is no reason [...] to believe [the sentence] would be overturned" and that it "remains good law". The defense further requested that the court reduce Mitchell's two felony convictions to misdemeanors; Fritz declined, saying, "There is no legal authority that allows or instructs this court to weigh those consequences and reduce the criminal sentence mandated by statute." Fritz did authorize Mitchell for a
work release program, which would permit her to leave the jail during the day to work and return in the evening. He also permitted Mitchell to serve her time in
Ramsey County, rather than Becker County, where the crime occurred and where she was convicted. Mitchell's attorney reported that Mitchell has "struggled to find work" but did "recently land a job in fast food". Mitchell began her sentence in October 2025. Mitchell was released early from her 180-day sentence on January 25, 2026. She appealed both her criminal conviction and the $26,318.03 restitution she was ordered to pay the victim. ==Personal life==