In 1984, Nordenberg received the first
Excellence-in-Teaching Award from Pitt's School of Law and, in 1985, the ''Chancellor's Distinguished Teaching Award
from the University of Pittsburgh. He was named Distinguished Service Professor of Law'' in 1994. In 1997, he was honored as
Person of the Year in Education by Vectors, a community service organization in Pittsburgh. He was named
Pittsburgher of the Year and
Co-Pittsburgher of the Year by
Pittsburgh Magazine in 1999 and 2001, respectively. in June 2005, the university's board of trustees announced the establishment of the endowed Chancellor Mark A. Nordenberg University Chair position to honor the Chancellor's 10 years of leadership. In December 2007, by resolution of the Pitt Student Government Board, the recreation room on the ground floor of the
William Pitt Union was named ''Nordy's Place'' in honor of the Chancellor whom the board deemed a student favorite and worthy of the honor. In 2009, Nordenberg was honored with the
2009 Presidential Leadership Award by
The Gordie Foundation and
Outside the Classroom Award for his role in overseeing Pitt's mission to combat binge drinking. He also serves on the board of directors of
UPMC and
The Bank of New York Mellon. On October 26, 2012, the Pitt Board of Trustees announced a $10 million scholarship fund and the naming of a new campus residence hall,
Nordenberg Hall, in honor Nordenberg, citing his role in transforming Pitt in 17 years leading the school. On February 6, 2014, Nordenberg was presented with the
Louis and Barbara Thiel Distinguished Service Award by his alma mater,
Thiel College as part of their annual Founders' Day Convocation ceremonies. On February 6, 2014, Nordenberg was awarded the
Dapper Dan Dr. Freddie Fu Leadership Award in athletics. On April 8, 2014, Nordenberg, along with former
Carnegie Mellon University president
Jared Cohon, were named recipients of the
Elsie Hilliard Hillman Lifetime Achievement Award for Excellence in Public Service. On May 9, 2014, Nordenberg and Cohon were awarded the Chairman's award by the Carnegie Science Center of Pittsburgh for leadership in science, technology, and education. On May 12, 2014, the university's Staff Association Council and the University Senate announced it was honoring Nordenberg and his wife Nikki with a pair of commemorative benches that were placed outside the windows of the Chancellor's office in the
Cathedral of Learning. In 2016, he was awarded both the
Distinguished Leadership Award from the American Red Cross and the
Mary Schenley Medal for Parks and Stewardship from the Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy. In 2018, Nordenberg was recognized as a
Distinguished Alumni for Excellence and Leadership in Education by North Allegheny School District. In 2019, he was named a
Trustee Emeritus by Thiel College's Board of Trustees. In 2021, Nordenberg was awarded the
Lifetime Achievement in Governance by the National Association of Corporate Directors, Three Rivers Chapter. In 2025, Nordenberg was elected to the prestigious American Academy of Arts and Sciences, which was founded in 1780 to honor excellence and convene leaders from every field of human endeavor to examine new ideas and address issues of importance to the nation and the world. Also, in 2025, he was awarded the inaugural
Jim Roddey Leadership Award. He has been awarded honorary degrees by Carnegie Mellon University, the Community College of Allegheny County, Duquesne University, La Roche College, Thiel College and the University of Pittsburgh. ==Post-chancellorship==