Critical reception Oh My My received generally positive reviews from
music critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album received an
average score of 66, based on 4 reviews, which indicates "generally favorable reviews". Jon Reyes from
Idolator said the album served as a reminder of Tedder's songwriting talent, labeling "Lift Me Up", "Heaven", "Born" and "Fingertips" as standouts of the album, writing that "in these lies the heart of OneRepublic, a distillation of Tedder’s influence and his influences. It's a potpourri formula that, with
Oh My My, hasn’t lost its fragrance". Writing for
Cross Rhythms, Tony Cummings gave the album nine stars of ten and said it is "the band's most diverse project so far". Gracelyn Trast of
The Badger Herald praises the tracks with guest appearances, praising the way the band knew how to unite their passionate melodies with the characteristic style of the guest artists. In a less favorable review, Daniel Patrin from
Renowned for Sound wrote the album "displays an attempt at sounding different" but "just feed the appetite of supersaturated pop hunger". Writing for
Evening Standard, Andre Paine summarized the album as a "hard bloated record loaded with feelings of self-indulgence", but praised the tracks "A.I." and "NbHD", saying that both "underlines Tedder’s technical ability in the studio".
Year-end lists ==Commercial performance==