Mandy Patinkin played Che for the American premiere production and recording, and sings the song. Author William A. Everett wrote in his book
The A to Z of the Broadway Musical that Patinkin's singing and portrayal of Che "interacted on a psychological level with the title character (played by
Patti LuPone), challenging her actions and motivations." In the 1996 film
Evita, the song is sung by actor
Antonio Banderas and singer
Madonna. In the film, Che muses while in an empty bar following the lavish funeral procession for Eva Perón, and then on the streets of Buenos Aires as the community mourns and then riots. Eva's lyrics come during a pan over her funeral casket and is not sung directly by Eva. It begins with Spanish guitars as Banderas takes the lead vocals, with a changing choir throughout. Author J. Randy Taraborrelli complemented Madonna's singing in the book,
Madonna: An Intimate Biography, describing her vocals as "supple and strong". This view was shared by author
Lucy O'Brien in
Madonna: Like an Icon who said that "the sweetness and the power of Madonna's voice comes out as never before on these tracks". It also received positive review from Paul Verna of
Billboard, who listed the "flamenco flavored" song as a highlight from the
soundtrack. For the 2006 First West End Revival of
Evita, actor Matt Rawle portrayed Che and sang the song. Michael Billington from
The Guardian received it negatively, saying that "Lacking any coherent idea, the show is motored by a succession of Lloyd Webber songs: '
Another Suitcase in Another Hall', ... 'Oh What a Circus', 'High Flying, Adored' and all the rest." While reviving the play for Broadway in 2012, singer
Ricky Martin was signed to play Che. According to Joe Dziemianowicz from
Daily News, Martin's performance as Che gave it "a great big touch of star quality... He also gives an appealing performance in the role of Che," the writer added. James Hebert from
The San Diego Union-Tribune complimented Martin for setting "the tone right away in the opening number 'Oh What a Circus'" with his "bemused, smilingly cynical" characterization of Che. In the 2014 Second West End Revival of the play, the role of Che was played by
Marti Pellow from Scottish rock band
Wet Wet Wet. Natalie Banyard complimented the choice of Pellow as Che, adding in an article for
Bristol Post that "Never was there a more inspired piece of casting than that of [Pellow] as [Che Guevara] in
Evita." Banyard also noticed that there was "no hint of Marti's
Scottish brogue as he stops the show with his renditions of 'Oh What a Circus' and 'The Lady's Got Potential'."
Hank Marvin performed an instrumental version of the song on his 1997 album
Hank Marvin and the Shadows Play the Music of Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice. ==Track listing==