2005 Citigroup advice Reportedly, Mercer Oliver Wyman was the unnamed consulting firm that recommended
Citigroup expand parts of their fixed income business in 2005, including in
collateralised debt obligations, which led to more than $50 billion in losses during the
2008 financial crisis and ultimately necessitated a rescue by the U.S. government. The firm made similar recommendations to
UBS, which expanded its CDO portfolio, suffered huge losses and had to be bailed out by the Swiss government. Some claim that the Wyman analysis included warnings and precautions about the
structured product market. Mercer Oliver Wyman declined to comment in both cases, citing
client confidentiality.
2006 Irish Bank endorsement In 2007, Oliver Wyman proclaimed the
Anglo-Irish Bank as the "best bank in the world" at the
World Economic Forum. A year later, on March 17, 2008, the Irish stock market plunged as investors globally dumped shares in fear of the United States
subprime mortgage crisis. The property bubble in Ireland burst, and the AIB's investments were heavily exposed. The price of their stock collapsed in what became known as the St. Patrick's Day Massacre, and the bank ultimately needed $30 billion in government bailouts to be nationalised. Oliver Wyman faced criticism for their earlier endorsement. The firm responded by saying that the 2006 “best bank” accolade was based solely on a backward-looking review of shareholder returns. In a statement to the
Financial Times, they said “Today one sees that differently. It would not have been a good idea to invest in Anglo Irish... We also unfortunately did not forecast the financial crisis in 2006.” The event damaged Oliver Wyman's reputation in Ireland, with future assignments coming under heavy scrutiny. Despite this, the firm continues to be hired widely in Europe and has audited 130 of the largest banks in the eurozone. Oliver Wyman ran the tests that set the terms of the
2012 Spanish bailout, prevented the privatization of
Slovene banks in 2013, advised on the sale of rescued Italian banks in 2016, and developed methods to combat money laundering in Malta. The firm is hired particularly often by the "troika" of international lenders: the
European Central Bank, the
European Commission, and the
International Monetary Fund.
2012 LIBOR decommission Hailed as the world's most important number, the London Inter-Bank Offered Rate, or
LIBOR, is an interest rate used as a benchmark for an estimated $340 trillion financial contracts worldwide. In 2012, Oliver Wyman was hired by the
British Bankers' Association to provide technical assistance in reviewing how the rate was set after a preliminary investigation uncovered significant fraud and collusion among banks. Although LIBOR had lost the confidence of market participants after the investigation, it was unclear whether there was a rate that could replace it. Oliver Wyman urged caution during the transition period, pointing out that “[s]ince the proposed alternative rates are calculated differently, payments under contracts referencing the new rates will differ from those referencing LIBOR. The transition will change firms’ market risk profiles, requiring changes to risk models, valuation tools, product design and hedging strategies.” The report projected that banks would need to spend an astonishing $1.2 billion to transition away from LIBOR. In accordance with these conclusions, the UK
Financial Conduct Authority decided to decommission LIBOR gradually, with official discontinuation set for 2021. In 2013, Oliver Wyman was hired by the
International Swaps and Derivatives Association to address a similar case of manipulation of the worldwide common
reference rate value for fixed
interest rate swap rates, also known as
ISDAFIX. The firm invented the current methodology to calculate the value based on regulated
electronic trading quotes.
2013 Kuwaiti joint venture In 2013, the
Kuwait Investment Authority and
Kuwait Fund for Arab Economic Development announced a joint venture with Oliver Wyman. The former two organizations would provide strategic relationships, and Oliver Wyman would provide consultants to create a subsidiary known as "Tri International Consulting Group". The unique arrangement allowed Oliver Wyman to bypass traditional barriers to entry in the Middle East, such as a shortage of
Arabic speakers, and establish long-term work availability. In
Kuwait, Oliver Wyman operates exclusively under the Tri International name. In 2018, the group was hired to advise on an
initial public offering of the $90 billion Kuwaiti
stock market, a process which had been held up for years due to political infighting in the country. The firm has also advised on debt strategies during periods of oil revenue decline and planned the installation of smart energy infrastructure across Kuwait.
2015 Eskom-McKinsey scandal In 2015, partners from Oliver Wyman met with representatives from major
South African institutions, including
Eskom,
Transnet, and the
Department of Cooperative Governance. The meetings were organized by a local consulting firm Trillian, which was majority-owned by an associate of the infamous
Gupta family. Trillian proposed that they could continue bringing influential South African clients to Oliver Wyman, who could then identify areas where clients could save money, and be paid back a percentage of the savings. Oliver Wyman rejected this proposal following an assessment of Trillian, and did not take on any of the firm's clients. In the same year,
McKinsey & Company took on a R1.6 billion ($117 million) contract with Eskom through Trillian. Trillian claims that it was operating as a subcontractor of McKinsey on the project. McKinsey initially denied that the existence of a subcontractor relationship, and stated that they only "worked alongside" Trillian. However, in September, a letter written by a McKinsey director authorizing Eskom to pay Trillian as a subcontractor was leaked by a former Trillian executive, Bianca Goodman. Goodman alleged that Trillian was
gatekeeping access to key South African clients, and that McKinsey was charging artificially high rates in order to give half of their fees to Trillian. McKinsey denied the allegations, stating that their price was "in line with similar projects we, and other firms, undertake in South Africa and elsewhere around the world.” Eskom then commissioned Oliver Wyman to investigate its contract with McKinsey. Oliver Wyman's final report found that the fee structure was "very unusual", raised multiple concerns regarding billing, and advised the company to take legal action against McKinsey and Trillian. After receiving the report, Eskom made false statements to the South African newspaper
Business Day about its conclusions, claiming that Oliver Wyman found that all payments were fair. Upon publication, Oliver Wyman demanded retraction of the false statements. A representative from the
Democratic Alliance party ultimately required Eskom to give Oliver Wyman's report to the
South African Parliament for verification. Under scrutiny, Eskom issued a correction to their previous statements regarding the content of the report in August 2017. Spokesperson
Natasha Mazzone declared "It is... apparent that Eskom procured the services of Oliver Wyman. Yet, when the advice was not in favour of the Guptas, they blatantly chose to ignore it." On the basis of the Wyman report, the Democratic Alliance party filed criminal charges against McKinsey and Trillian for
fraud,
racketeering, and
collusion. McKinsey repaid R1 billion while Trillian was taken to court for R600 million of the fees they had been paid initially. In 2017, McKinsey issued an apology for making “several errors in judgment” and in 2018, the firm acknowledged that it had overcharged in what
The Financial Times described as "South Africa’s biggest ever
corruption scandal."
2017 Saudi mega-city leak In 2017, the
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia announced plans to invest $500 billion to develop a futuristic
smart city known as
Neom along the
Red Sea. To help build this city, Crown Prince
Mohammad bin Salman hired consultants from Oliver Wyman as well as
Boston Consulting Group and
McKinsey & Company to make recommendations on urban planning, economics and legal systems. Over 2,300 pages of project planning were leaked and published by
The Wall Street Journal in 2019, revealing that the consultancies had made recommendations which relied on technology that did not yet exist such as flying taxis, robot maids, and an artificial moon. In a statement to the press, Neom said “the involvement of consultants has been productive and valuable" and that "Neom is all about things that are necessarily future-oriented and visionary... so we are talking about technology that is cutting edge and beyond, and in some cases still in development and maybe theoretical." The project is scheduled for completion in 2025. The case brought light to potential
human rights abuses involved in the creation of the city, with the firms making recommendations on how to forcibly relocate indigenous
Howeitat tribes, develop a 24/7 surveillance system using
facial recognition technology, and enforce
Sharia law. It reignited discussion in the
United States regarding Saudi Arabia's dependence on American management firms, which have worked on hundreds of projects for the kingdom. In addition to working on government projects, Oliver Wyman is also a sponsor of the Saudi
Future Investment Initiative.
2018 Australian stress tests In 2018, the
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) required the
Commonwealth Bank to conduct stress tests due to a series of scandals that had affected the bank's reputation. Three panel members were selected to oversee the review. Two voted to appoint Oliver Wyman to conduct the tests, while the other, former chairman of the
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission Graeme Samuel, strongly opposed. Samuel argued that external consultants should not be hired, and further suggested that executives who could not resolve their own governance issues should not remain in positions of leadership. By majority vote, Oliver Wyman was hired for an undisclosed sum in the millions to conduct the tests, and ARPA stated that their final report was "valuable". In an interview with the
Australian Financial Review, Samuel stated that it was "a waste of money." The firm went on to conduct similar tests for
Westpac in 2019. == Recruitment ==