After touring extensively to support
Something to Write Home About, the band was looking to depart from their high-energy powerpop style in lieu of a slower, more mellow sound. In 2000, vocalist/guitarist
Matt Pryor moved to Boston, Massachusetts, and drummer Ryan Pope moved to Los Angeles, California. As a result, the members only saw each other when they embarked on tours. By the end of the year, they had managed to fit in ten rehearsals, writing eight songs in the process. Their goal was to write 30 songs, which they plan to whittle down to 12. Following this, the group received a number of tour offers that they accepted, such as opening for
Weezer and
Green Day. Unlike the band's previous work, which they played extensively at live shows before recording,
On a Wire was written entirely in the studio, leading to a much less energetic sound. The group eventually reconvened in Kansas and wrote new material for their next album. Soon afterwards, they accumulated 25 songs. The band compiled a list of potential producers for their next album.
Scott Litt approached the group after liking the demos he heard. The rest of the album was recorded in January and February 2002 at Tarquin Studios in
Bridgeport,
Connecticut with Litt over the course of six weeks. Keyboardist
James Dewees stated in an interview with
AP Magazine that Litt "knew how to make bands sound good, but he was taking a band that was used to playing four-chord rock songs. We didn't know what we were doing." According to Pope, Litt didn't allow Dewees much control with his instrument: "James would go into something and (Scott Litt) would be like, 'No jazz chords! Don't do that! One hand!'" Litt mixed the recordings while
Peter Katis acted as engineer.
Ed Rose, who had worked with the band previously, provided additional creative input on "Overdue" while Carl Nappa did digital editing. Katis did additional mixing at
The Hit Factory in New York City later in February with assistance from Jamie Duncan.
Stephen Marcussen then mastered the recordings at Marcussen Mastering. ==Composition==