Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths has been critically acclaimed. At the 2009
Angoulême International Comics Festival, the manga won the
Prize for Inheritance. In 2012, it was nominated for a
Harvey Award in the Best American Edition of Foreign Material category. It was selected for the
Eisner Award in the categories
Best U.S. Edition of International Material—Asia and Best Reality-Based Work, winning the former at
San Diego Comic-Con. According to a compilation by Deb Aoki of
About.com,
Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths was considered the best new manga of 2011 because it was included in 18 critics lists of best comics/graphic novels. Aoki said the manga is "dense with details, and filled with pathos, humor and horror".
Pastes Garrett Martin wrote that the "realistic depictions of normal men trapped in a horrible situation" makes
Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths "brutally honest". Brigid Alverson of
MTV Geek said, "this is not an easy story to read, but its historical importance and the lessons it holds for the future are undeniable". Noel Murray writing in
The A.V. Club said the manga's artwork is "detailed, often beautiful illustrations of small Pacific islands with characters rendered far less elaborately". Karen Green of
Comixology wrote that the "story is so human and its message so powerful" and that is a good book to eliminate the preconceptions American may have of the Japanese Army that are frequently propagated by Hollywood. Dan Kois and Glen Weldon of
NPR,
Comic Book Resources, Ed Sizemore of Manga Worth Reading, and
Publishers Weekly included it on their lists of best comic books of 2011. Further, in 2014, Joe Gross of the
Rolling Stone qualified it as the 46th "Best Non-Superhero Graphic Novel" of all time.
David Maine wrote for
PopMatters that "there is little here to criticize. Perhaps some of the transitions are a bit abrupt, [and] maybe some of the characterization could be sharper." Similarly, Sean Michael Robinson of
The Comics Journal said
Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths for its theme "as well as its many strengths and virtues, it is a very difficult book to criticize".
Television adaptation On August 12, 2007,
NHK General TV broadcast , a Japanese television drama based on
Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths. It was written by Takuya Nishioka and produced by Tsuyoshi Yanagawa, and starred
Teruyuki Kagawa as Shigeru Mizuki. The drama was awarded the Excellence Prize for television program at the 45th
Galaxy Awards by the Japan Council for Better Television and Radio. At the
34th Hoso Bunka Foundation Awards,
Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths won the awards for Best Television Drama, Best Actor (Kagawa), and Best Production (Yanagawa).
Cast •
Teruyuki Kagawa as Shigeru Mizuki/Maruyama •
Tomoko Tabata as Nunoe •
Sansei Shiomi as Honda •
Kyūsaku Shimada as Ishiyama •
Takaaki Enoki as Kido • Yukiya Kitamura as Akasaki •
Renji Ishibashi as a company commander • Hiroshi Kanbe as Kayama •
Haruhiko Jō as the chief of staff •
Tetsurō Sagawa as the brigadier •
Atsushi Miyauchi as Mizumoto •
Masako Nozawa as Kitarō (voice) •
Isamu Tanonaka as Medama Oyaji (voice) •
Chikao Ōtsuka as Nezumi Otoko (voice) ==Notes==