Critical Our Love to Admire received mostly positive reviews from music critics, although it was more polarizing compared to the band's previous releases. At
Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album received an average score of 70/100, based on 37 professional critic reviews, which indicates "generally favorable reviews".
Playlouder gave it all five stars and said, "The band have colonised the rich turf at the intersection of meticulously structured mope-rock and free-flowing three-chord pop, where moments of resignation cosy up alongside twinkling hopes for the future like Winehouse to the sauce."
Hot Press gave it a favorable review and said that the album "makes for hugely rewarding listening."
Uncut gave the album four stars out of five and called it "a majestic, grandiose, machine-tooled album, subtly orchestrated with gothic pianos and doomy organs."
URB also gave it four stars out of five and called it "the type of strung-out confession that fills the junkie mold of classic
Bright Lights Interpol--a welcomed revival after the wayward
Antics."
Now likewise gave the album four stars out of five and said that "In terms of writing and production, this may be Interpol at their best."
Billboard gave it a favorable review and said that the band "retains its flair for dramatic images and ominous guitar lines on its major-label debut, but with producer/ mixer Rich Costey onboard, these signatures uncoil into more complex soundscapes."
BBC Music gave it a positive review and said that Interpol are "tighter than a laser-guided smart bomb, the beats are more swingy, and Carlos D's bass and keys are even more expressive and swooning."
The Boston Globe likewise gave it a favorable review and said, "The foreboding melancholy of 'Turn on the Bright Lights' has eroded into a sound that's less idiosyncratic; by design or accident, that broad-brush aesthetic coincides with the band's move from an indie label (Matador) to a major one (Capitol)."
Q and
Mojo both gave the album a score of four stars out of five.
The Phoenix gave the album three stars out of four and called it "well worth exploring".
The A.V. Club gave it a B and said it "delivers exactly what's promised, which for fans will be exactly enough."
Under the Radar gave the album seven stars out of ten and said it "isn't going to change many minds--those who already liked the band will find plenty to please, and vice versa."
Paste gave the album three-and-a-half stars out of five and said that it "may not be [the band's]
Sgt. Pepper, but it's still filled with morbidly catchy treats."
The Village Voice gave it a positive review and said that "Somehow the band manages to sound insincere and gorgeous at the same time."
Prefix Magazine also gave it a positive review and said it "sounds more or less like the last two [CDs], and that's its biggest problem." Other reviews are average, mixed or negative:
Yahoo! Music UK gave the album six stars out of ten and said of Interpol: "Crucially, it seems their ability to write a magisterially moving song such as "NYC" or "Obstacle No 1", both from their debut, seems to have abandoned them. In fairness, sonically speaking, this is their best effort yet."
Blender gave it three stars out of five and also said of Interpol: "In fleshing out the contours of a sound once slavishly indebted to early-'80s titans like JD [Joy Division] and the Smiths, they've nuanced the moods Banks moons over. Awesome for him. Only so-so for us."
The Guardian gave it three stars out of five and called it "undoubtedly impressive: impressive enough, in fact, to counter the fact that Interpol are pretty light on ideas of their own."
The Austin Chronicle gave the album two stars out of five and said it "could use more Carlos D.'s low-end bass/keyboard flourishes. Perhaps it's time to turn the lights out."
Stylus Magazine gave it a D saying that "they ape New Order's "Movement," surely that combo's most static and dullest album. Dengler and rather good drummer Sam Fogarino don't get many chances to shine, letting guitarist Daniel Kessler create the kind of textures that often get mistaken for progress."
Commercial Our Love to Admire scored Interpol's best chart positions in their career, debuting inside the top five of the UK and US albums charts, reaching number three on the
European Albums Chart and selling over 154,000 copies in its first week worldwide. The album debuted at number four on the
Billboard 200, selling 73,000 copies, but then dropped to number 26 the next week with 22,000 copies. After 10 weeks, the album dropped off the chart, but by January 2009 it had sold 209,000 copies. It's notable that while the band's third album has sold far fewer copies in the US than their previous two did—the others have each moved close to 500,000 units—
Our Love to Admire is still Interpol's highest-charting disc.
Retrospective commentary In a 2018 interview with
Vice, lead singer
Paul Banks listed
Our Love to Admire as his least favorite of the band's albums. Banks had just gotten sober and the pressure of working with a major label ultimately resulted in a "stressful" and "unpleasant" experience that was also "way too much work". The group had similar issues with the production of their fourth album
Interpol, but said that the group was "proud of the music" on both, with Banks saying: "some of my favorite songs we ever wrote are on these two records, so it's not like the situation was bad and the record is bad." Drummer
Sam Fogarino also cited issues with the new label during the album's production, claiming that the band felt welcome at first, but once the label was sold, that changed: "We're a number now, we're a number on a data print out." ==Track listing==