The immediate popular response was overwhelmingly negative. There were an estimated two million viewers at the beginning of the special, and by the time it finished one million viewers had switched off.
BT then received thousands of directory enquires for the Channel 4 complaints department. Scenes highlighted as being disturbing included Morris posing as a rapper who dates children, who is named "
JLB8" and performs with a dummy of a child attached to his crotch, BBC entertainment editor William Gallagher criticised the celebrity campaign segments as too repetitive and numerous, writing that it simply padded out the programme's runtime, concluding "It was not a great piece of comedy but it was pretty good [...] it had the right idea about how vilified anyone can be for the mere mention of paedophilia." Tom Gatti for
New Statesman praised the pacing as densely packed and spry, pointing out several jokes that occur only within the first two and a half minutes and commenting, "In a sketch show, some of these ideas might have run for several minutes each: not in the ultra-compressed atmosphere of
Brass Eye." Home Secretary
David Blunkett said he was "dismayed". In an interview with
The Observer,
Ian Hislop referred to the special as sharing a similar satirical remit to the magazine
Private Eye of which he is editor, commenting, "I thought that the Brass Eye on paedophilia caught that surreal amorality of television when it is pretending to take issues seriously." An editorial piece in
The Guardian stated, "As it happens, we do not stand with Channel 4 on the substance of the programme. Brass Eye was a deeply unpleasant piece of television that degraded children much more than it satirised either the media or celebrities or politicians." An editorial piece in
The Daily Telegraph criticised the involvement of senior politicians, "On hearing the word [paedophilia], otherwise calm people are expected to assume an attitude of incoherent rage. It is worth pointing out, if only for the record, that Brass Eye was a parody, not of paedophilia, but of the low-grade investigative programmes that seem to dominate evening television" In 2019,
The Guardian ranked "Paedogeddon" at number 37 in their list of "The 100 best TV shows of the 21st century". ==References==