The album was recorded with, and co-produced by, Mark Freegard at Waterfront Studios in
Hoboken, New Jersey. According to Madder Rose guitarist
Billy Cote, the band recorded
Panic On just after they had finished touring, and had only ten days to prepare for the recording sessions. He has also said that it was very easy to record the album's songs. After the album was recorded, the band's bassist, Matt Verta-Ray, left the band, whereupon they had five weeks to choose a new one; they settled on Chris Giammalvo from
Eve's Plum. ==Critical reception==