While Noonan's speechwriting has been praised, her books and
Wall Street Journal columns have been the source of criticism and mockery. Critics have singled out her reliance on personal anecdotes to make broad assertions about current events and changes in American politics and society. During
Hurricane Katrina, Noonan called for looters in New Orleans to be shot.
Henry Giroux called it a "barely coded rationale to shoot low-income Black people." claiming that
Elián González was rescued from a shipwreck by a group of dolphins that "surrounded him like a contingent of angels", adding that this should be seen "as possible evidence of the reasonable assumption that God's creatures had been commanded to protect one of God's children."
Richard Cohen described her as "unhinged" in
The Washington Post. In August 2019, Noonan was mocked for writing a column on
Donald Trump's support among
Hispanic Americans which centered on a conversation she had with a
Dominican friend who worked at the deli counter at her grocery store. Recurring themes in Noonan's books and columns include the decline of civility, social graces, religiosity, patriotism, bipartisanship and statesmanship in contemporary American politics and society, as well as enduring praise for past conservative political figures such as Ronald Reagan and
George H. W. Bush. As a result, her writing is criticized for being overly nostalgic. In June 2019, after Noonan called on congressional Democrats to censure President Trump in the wake of the
Mueller report, he attacked her on
Twitter, calling her "simplistic" and claiming that she "is stuck in the past glory of Reagan". In June 2022, Trump issued a statement calling Noonan a "weak and frail
RINO... who did much less for Ronald Reagan than she claims, and who actually said bad things about him and his ability to speak" after she wrote in the
Wall Street Journal that the Republican Party was "rejecting" Trump in the aftermath of the
2021 United States Capitol attack.
Jeet Heer criticized her writing about the
Columbia University pro-Palestinian campus protests in
The Nation. ==Books==