Many ancient and modern interpreters favor identification of Scheria with the island of
Corfu, which is within 110 km (68 miles) of Ithaca.
Thucydides, in his
Peloponnesian War, identifies Scheria as Corfu or, with its ancient name, Corcyra. In I.25.4, he records the
Corinthians' resentment of the Corcyraeans, who "could not repress a pride in the high naval position of an island whose nautical renown dated from the days of its old inhabitants, the Phaeacians." Locals on Corfu had long claimed this, based on the rock off the west coast of the island, which is supposedly the ship that carried
Odysseus back to Ithaca, but was
turned to stone by
Poseidon, to punish the Phaeacians for helping his enemy, The Phaeacians did not participate in the
Trojan War. The Greek name Φαίακες is derived from
phaiós (φαιός “gray”). The Phaeacians in the
Odyssey did not know Odysseus (although they knew
of him, as evidenced by the tales of
Demodocus), so they called him a "stranger". Odysseus however was the king of the majority of the
Ionian Islands, not only of
Ithaca, but also "of
Cephallenia,
Neritum,
Crocylea,
Aegilips,
Same and
Zacynthus" so if Scheria was Corfu, it would be surprising that the citizens of one of the Ionian Islands did not know Odysseus. Furthermore, when Odysseus reveals his identity, he says to the nobles: "[…] if I outlive this time of sorrow, I may be counted as your friend, though I live so far away from all of you" indicating that Scheria was far away from Ithaca. Some suggest that many characteristics of the Phaeacians, including their seafaring and relaxed lifestyle, are suggestive of
Minoan Crete. Aside from the seafaring prowess, the palace walls that 'shone like the Sun' are read to be covered not by bronze but
orichalcum. The latter similarities make Scheria also suggestive of
Plato's account of
Atlantis. Since ancient times, some scholars who examined the work and geography of Homer, have suggested that Scheria was located in the
Atlantic Ocean, among them were
Strabo and
Plutarch.
Geographical account by Strabo Approximately eight centuries after
Homer, the geographer
Strabo criticized
Polybius on the
geography of the Odyssey. Strabo proposed that Scheria and
Ogygia were located in the middle of the
Atlantic Ocean. == See also ==