The cormorant
family Phalacrocoracidae has traditionally been included – like all other
birds with fully webbed toes – in the
Pelecaniformes. But the namesake
pelicans (Pelecanidae) are actually closer relatives of
storks (Ciconiidae) than of cormorants. Hence, it has been proposed to separate the Phalacrocoracidae and relatives as
order Phalacrocoraciformes. More recent evidence indicates that they and the
darters actually belong in the order
Suliformes, alongside the
boobies and
gannets.
red-faced cormorant (
U. urile, shown here in breeding plumage) is the pelagic cormorant's
sister species This
species was formerly placed in the catch-all
genus Phalacrocorax. Modern authors were previously reserved about uniting all cormorants in one "
wastebin genus", but most revisions published had on
phylogenetic merit. Though it was proposed to place the pelagic cormorant in
Stictocarbo for example, this is quite certainly wrong, as the present species is by no means closely related to the
spotted shag (
P. punctatus), the
type species of
Stictocarbo. Similarly,
Leucocarbo would refer to the group around the
imperial shag (
P. atriceps) complex, which occurs on the opposite end of the Earth from
P. pelagicus. The supposed "cliff shag"
subfamily Leucocarboninae is entirely
paraphyletic cannot be accepted as originally circumscribed. If subfamilies are to be accepted in the Phalacrocoracidae, the pelagic shag and its relatives would go in the Phalacrocoracinae like most
Northern Hemisphere cormorants and shags, while Leucocarboninae would include mainly
Southern Hemisphere taxa. Another theory held that the
genus name for the pelagic cormorant, if
Phalacrocorax was to be split up, would be
Compsohalieus. This name would apply to the group around its
type species (
Brandt's cormorant,
P. penicillatus). This is a
North Pacific clade, which apart from Brandt's and the pelagic cormorant also includes the
red-faced cormorant (
P. urile) and probably also the
extinct spectacled cormorant (
P. perspicillatus). They all have black feet, and in breeding plumage grow white
filoplumes on the head and/or neck, and usually also two head-crests and white
thigh patches like the present species does. They also share the back-thrown head during the "yawning" and the rapid wing-flutter in
courtship display. Among the
Compsohalieus group, the red-faced cormorant is the
sister species of
P. pelagicus. Apart from looking almost alike, these two species also "yawn" many times in a row instead of giving the display just once, twist their bodies before taking flight during courtship, and the male and female post-landing calls are identical. The point-and-gargle response to threats is also an
apomorphy of these two species. In 2014, a study was published supporting this treatment, albeit classifying the species in the genus
Urile rather than
Compsohalieus. The
IUCN,
BirdLife International, and the
IOC have since followed this classification, legitimizing it. (κόραξ, "raven").
Pelagicus is – like the
English loanword "
pelagic" – derived from (πελᾶγιος, "of the open seas").
Compsohalieus, meanwhile, means "sleek fisher"; it derives from (κομψός, "elegant" or "sleek") + ' (ἇλιεύς, "fisherman").
Urile is a term coined by
Bonaparte in 1855 as the species name for the red-faced cormorant. However, a subsequent analysis of a larger number of comparison specimens of the pelagic cormorant – mainly from birds that fell victim to the
Exxon Valdez oil spill – determined that the bones were attributable to small females of the latter species, and that their apparent distinctness was due to the original
canonical analysis being distorted by insufficient specimens. The researchers also found that contrary to what was generally assumed, pelagic cormorants from the Aleutians were generally small birds – as opposed to western Alaskan individuals, which are usually very large. If the Aleutian population were to be considered a distinct
subspecies, the name
kenyoni would apply. Verification of subspecies status would require
DNA sequence analyses however, since the differences in
morphology are not large and there is much variation between individuals. In 2003, during an USFWS survey three small pelagic cormorants whose bills appeared to be red were noted at
Karab Cove on
Agattu Island. It may be that these were
kenyoni, but whether the bill color distinguishes the presumed subspecies or whether it is due to a simple
mutation has not been determined. The large birds from the
Prince William Sound region were formerly called
U. p. robustus, but are not considered distinct today. Since there appear to be at least two recognizable and
allopatric size groups in the northern subspecies alone, more research is clearly necessary. ==Footnotes==