"
Say Say Say" was released as the album's lead single in October 1983. A duet with Michael Jackson, it reached number 2 in the UK and number 1 in the US, where it remained for six weeks through to early in 1984.
Pipes of Peace peaked at number 4 in the UK and number 15 in the US. Following "Say Say Say",
the album's title track became a UK number 1, while in the US, the
flipside "So Bad" hit number 23. Critical reaction was less positive than that which greeted
Tug of War, many feeling that
Pipes of Peace was a weaker execution of its predecessor's formula. In addition, according to McCartney biographer
Howard Sounes, the album's commercial reception was "slightly disappointing, considering the quality of the work". Sounes views
Pipes of Peace and its predecessor as "abounding with well-crafted tunes" that almost match the standard of McCartney's work with the Beatles; yet, he adds, the two albums "must be marked down for a surfeit of love ballads with lamentable lyrics". Reviewing the 2015 reissue of
Pipes of Peace, for
Pitchfork, Ron Hart notes that, at the time of release, "Some critics derided McCartney for aging gracelessly", yet "a good listen to the album today reveals some ways it was ahead of its time." Hart writes of the song "Tug of Peace": "an early, primitive version of a
mash-up that brought together the title cuts of these underappreciated albums. The blend is clunky, but it foreshadows his electronic music work as
the Fireman and on
Liverpool Sound Collage." By contrast, Jeff Strowe of
PopMatters considers that the album "presents McCartney at his most regrettable", and views "Pipes of Peace" and "Tug of Peace" as, respectively, a "woefully underdeveloped title track" and a "dreadful mashup". Strowe writes more favourably of "Say Say Say", however, describing it as "catchy in that pure '80s manner", and highlights "Sweetest Little Show" and "Average Person" as "a nice one-two punch of refreshing creativity that give the proceedings a much needed spark of interest and vitality". ==Track listing==