P. phelpsae Pittsfordipterus phelpsae is only known by two well preserved specimens, the
holotype and paratype (NYSM 10102 and NYSM 10103, both at the
New York State Museum). Three years later, Kjellesvig-Waering decided to assign the same species to the
subgenus Nanahughmilleria. In 1966, Kjellesvig-Waering, together with the American paleontologist Kenneth Edward Caster, recognized that
H. (N.) phelpsae was sufficiently different from the other eurypterids and erected the genus
Pittsfordipterus based on the morphology of its genital appendage.
P. maria In 1907,
John Mason Clarke described the eurypterid species
Eurypterus maria based on fossils from the
Shawangunk Mountains,
New York. The carapace of this species was somewhat elongate, regularly rounded and with subparallel (almost parallel)
lateral margins with subcentral (near the centre of the carapace) eyes of a crescentic (half moon shaped) form. The segments were wide. A rapid contraction was observed in the postabdomen (segments 8 to 12) reminiscent of the
scorpion abdomen, which seems to indicate a nepionic (immature) condition. Similar contraction is present in other immature eurypterids as well. The only known adult eurypterids to possess it are
Carcinosoma scorpioides and several species of
Eusarcana, in which the tail was heavily specialized. The
ocelli (light-sensitive simple eyes) were located in a line that connected the centers of the
compound eyes, and were located on a large prominent mound. The abdomen was thin and tapered towards the telson, which was lanceolate. The third and fourth segments were the widest of the preabdomen. Each
tergite of the preadomen was arched with a narrow flat strip (the epimera). In this species, the appendages are rare, and only swimming legs have been found in some mature specimens. These were short and protuberant. The eighth segment or paddle was long and elliptical, with a ninth segment forming a terminal claw. In 1961, Erik N. Kjellesvig-Waering reclassified
E. maria to the then new genus
Parahughmilleria.
P. maria was then not subject to any detailed analysis or examination for decades, merely appearing in the literature through being listed in taxonomic lists.
P. maria was referred to
Pittsfordipterus by James Lamsdell in 2025. This reassignment was based on the lateral eyes being elongated in several specimens. The lack of serrated edges on the paddle of the sixth appendage allowed Lamsdell to classify the species in
Pittsfordipterus rather than the closely related
Bassipterus. ==Classification==