Critical response Departures received generally positive reviews from critics. The
review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes sampled 109 reviewers and judged an 80% approval rating, with an
average score of 7.1 out of 10. The website's critical consensus states, "If slow and predictable,
Departures is a quiet, life affirming story". The aggregator
Metacritic gives the film 68 out of 100, based on 27 reviews, indicating "generally favorable reviews".
Domestic reviews Initial reviews in Japan were positive. In
Kinema Junpo, Tokitoshi Shioda called
Departures a turning point in Takita's career, a human drama capturing both laughter and tears, while in the same publication Masaaki Nomura described the film as a work of supple depth that perhaps indicated a move into Takita's mature period, praising the director for capturing a human feeling from Motoki's earnest encoffining performance. Writing in the
Yomiuri Shimbun, Seichi Fukunaga complimented Takita for using a moving, emotive story laden with humour to reverse prejudice against a taboo subject. He commended the performances of Motoki and Yamazaki, particularly their playing the serious Daigo against the befuddled Sasaki. In the
Asahi Shimbun, Sadao Yamane found the film admirably constructed and extolled the actors' performances. Yamane was especially impressed by the delicate hand movements Motoki displayed when he performed the encoffinment ceremony. Tomomi Katsuta in the
Mainichi Shimbun found
Departures a meaningful story that made the viewer think about the different lives people live, and the significance of someone dying. Writing in the same newspaper, Takashi Suzuki thought the film memorable but predictable, and Yūji Takahashi opined that the film's ability to find nobility in a prejudiced subject was an excellent accomplishment. Shōko Watanabe gave
Departures four out of five stars in
The Nikkei newspaper, praising the actors' unforced performances. Following the success of
Departures at the Academy Awards, critic
Saburō Kawamoto found the film to show a Japan that the Japanese could relate to, in that, in a nation whose customs put great weight on visits to ancestral graves, a death was always a family affair. He believed the film had a samurai beauty to it, with its many scenes of families sitting
seiza. Critic gave the film a 90% rating, and credited the performances of the two leads for much of the film's success. He praised its emotional impact and its balance of seriousness and humour, but was more critical of the father–son relationship, which he considered overdone. Maeda attributed the film's international success, despite its heavily Japanese content, to its clear depiction of Japanese views on life and death. He found the film's conceptual scale to have an affinity to that of Hollywood (something he considered lacking in most Japanese films). Reviewer Takurō Yamaguchi gave the film an 85% rating, and found the treatment of its subject charming. He praised its quiet emotional impact and humour, the interweaving of northern Japan scenery with Hisaishi's cello score, and the film's Japanese spirit. Media critic found a moving beauty in the dextrous hand movements Sasaki teaches Daigo for preparing bodies, and believed that a prior reading of the original script would deepen the viewer's understanding of the action. Mark Schilling of
The Japan Times gave the film four stars out of five, praising the acting though criticizing the apparent idealization of the encoffiners. He concluded that the film "makes a good case for the Japanese way of death."
International reviews critic Roger Ebert gave Departures'' a perfect four stars. Internationally,
Departures has received mixed—mostly positive—reviews. Ebert gave the film a perfect four stars, describing it as "rock-solid in its fundamentals" and highlighting its cinematography, music, and the casting of Yamazaki as Sasaki. He found that the result "functions flawlessly" and is "excellent at achieving the universal ends of narrative". He eventually put the movie in his collection of
Great Movies; the most recent film on the list. Derek Armstrong of
AllMovie gave the film four stars out of five, describing it as "a film of lyrical beauty" which is "bursting with tiny pleasures". In a four-star review, Byrnes described the film as a "moving meditation on the transience of life" which showed "great humanity", concluding "it's a beautiful film but take two hankies." Howell gave the film three stars out of four, praising its acting and cinematography. He wrote that
Departures "quietly subverts aesthetic and emotional expectations" without ever losing its "high-minded intent". In a three-and-a-half star review, Claudia Puig of
USA Today described
Departures as a "beautifully composed" film which, although predictable, was "emotional, poignant" and "profoundly affecting".
Philip French of
The Observer considered
Departures to be a "moving, gently amusing" film, which the director had "fastidiously composed". Sharkey found it an "emotionally wrenching trip with a quiet man", one which was well cast with "actors who move lightly, gracefully" in the various settings. In
Entertainment Weekly,
Owen Gleiberman gave the film a B−, considering it "tender and, at times, rather squishy", though certain to affect anyone who had lost a parent. Barber found
Departures to be "heartfelt, unpretentious, [and] slyly funny", worth watching (though ultimately predictable). Mike Scott gave the film three and a half stars out of four, finding that it was "a surprisingly uplifting examination of life and loss", with humour which perfectly complemented the "moving and meaningful story", but lent itself to characters "mug[ging] for the camera". Meanwhile,
Kevin Maher of
The Times described
Departures as a "
verklempt comedy" with wearisome "push-button crying", though he considered it saved by the quality of the acting, "stately" directing, and "dreamy" soundtrack. Another mixed review was published in
The Daily Telegraph, which described the film as a "safe and emotionally generous crowd-pleaser" that was not worthy of its Academy Award.
Philip Kennicott wrote in
The Washington Post that the film was "as polished as it is heavy-handed", predictable yet ready to break taboos, immersed in death yet incapable of escaping "the maddening Japanese taste for sentimentality". In
Variety, Eddie Cockrell wrote that the film offered "fascinating glimpses" of the encoffining ceremony but should have had a much shorter runtime. Paatsch gave
Departures three stars out of five, describing it as a "quaintly mournful flick" that "unfolds with a delicacy and precision that slowly captivates the viewer" but considering some scenes, such as the montage, "needlessly showy flourishes". Edward Porter of
The Sunday Times wrote that the film's success at the Academy Awards could be blamed on "a case of the Academy favouring bland sentimentality".
The A.V. Club Keith Phipps gave
Departures a C−, writing that though it featured "handsome shots of provincial life" and encoffining scenes with a "poetic quality", ultimately the film "drips from one overstated emotion to the next".
A. O. Scott wrote in
The New York Times that the film was "perfectly mediocre", predictable, and banal in its combination of humour and melodrama. Despite its sometimes touching moments, he considered
Departures "interesting mainly as an index of the Academy's hopelessly timid and conventional tastes".
Tony Rayns of
Film Comment gave a scathing review in which he denounced the script as "embarrassingly clunky and obvious", the acting as merely "adequate", and the film as but a "paean to the good-looking corpse". Adams gave
Departures two out of four stars, praising the emotionally and visually arresting scenes of encoffinments and "loving attention to the textures, tastes and behaviours of semi-rural Japan" but condemning the predictability of the plot; he wrote that "Forty-five minutes in, [viewers have] prepared a mental checklist of every turn that Daigo Kobayashi will face, then negotiate – and be danged if Takita doesn't deliver on every one".
Awards At the
32nd Japan Academy Prize ceremony held in February 2009,
Departures dominated the competition. It received a total of thirteen nominations, winning ten, including
Picture of the Year,
Screenplay of the Year (Koyama),
Director of the Year (Takita), and
Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role (Motoki). In the
Outstanding Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role category, Hirosue lost to
Tae Kimura of
All Around Us, while in the Outstanding Achievement in Art Direction category
Departures Tomio Ogawa lost to
Paco and the Magical Book Towako Kuwashima. Hisaishi, nominated for two Outstanding Achievement in Music awards, won for his scoring of Studio Ghibli's animated film
Ponyo. In response to the wins, Motoki said "It feels as if everything miraculously came together in balance this time with Okuribito".
Departures was submitted to the
81st Academy Awards as
Japan's submission for the
Best Foreign Language Film award. Although eleven previous Japanese films had won
Academy Awards in other categories, such as
Best Animated Feature or
Best Costume Design, the as-yet unattained Best Foreign Language Film award was highly coveted in the Japanese film industry.
Departures was not expected to win, owing to strong competition from the Israeli and French submissions (
Ari Folman's
Waltz with Bashir and
Laurent Cantet's
The Class, respectively), but was ultimately the victor at the February 2009 ceremony. This was considered a surprise by several film critics, and
The New York Times David Itzkoff termed
Departures "The Film That Lost Your Oscars Pool for You". Motoki, who was expecting the "wonderful" Israeli submission to win, was also surprised; he described himself as a "hanger-on who just observes the ceremony", and regretted "not walk[ing] with more confidence" upon his arrival.
Departures received recognition at a variety of film festivals, including the Audience Choice Award at the 28th
Hawaii International Film Festival, the Audience Choice Award at the 15th
Vilnius International Film Festival, the Grand Prix des Amériques at the 32nd Montreal World Film Festival, and Best Narrative Film at the 20th
Palm Springs International Film Festival. Motoki was selected as best actor at several ceremonies, including at the
Asian Film Awards, the
Asia Pacific Screen Awards, and the
Blue Ribbon Awards; he was also viewers' choice for best actor at the
Golden Rooster Awards. At the 29th
Hong Kong Film Awards,
Departures was selected as Best Asian Film, beating three Chinese films and
Ponyo. Following the 21st
Nikkan Sports Film Award ceremony, in which
Departures won Best Film and Best Director, Takita expressed surprise at the film's awards, saying "I did not know how well my work would be accepted." By December 2009 the film had won 98 awards.
Impact After the film's success, Sakata Location Box set up a hospitality service called
Mukaebito—a pun on the film's Japanese title indicating "one who greets or picks up" another, rather than "one who sends off". The service maintains shooting locations and provides maps of these locations for tourists. In 2009, Location Box opened the building that served as the NK Agent office to the public. For a fee, visitors could enter and view props from the film. Under a job creation program, between 2009 and 2013 the organization received ¥30 million from Yamagata Prefecture and ¥8 million from Sakata City for the building's maintenance and administration. The site attracted nearly 120,000 visitors in 2009, though numbers quickly fell; in 2013 there were fewer than 9,000 visitors. Safety fears due to the building's age led to the Sakata municipal government ending the organization's lease, and the building was closed again at the end of March 2014. At the time, the City Tourism division was considering options, such as limiting visits to the first two floors. The building used as the Concerto café has been open to the public since 2009 as the Kaminoyama Concerto Museum, and the Sakata Minato-za cinema has also been opened to tourists. Takita's hometown of
Takaoka, Toyama, maintains a Film Resources Museum; staff have reported that at times over a hundred Takita fans visit per day. The film's success generated greater interest in encoffining and the ''''. Even the model of hearse driven in the film was merchandised: the Mitsuoka Limousine Type 2-04, a smaller, less expensive version of the film's vehicle, was put on the market on 24 February 2009. The manufacturer,
Mitsuoka Motors, is located in Takita's home prefecture of Toyama. In 2013, Kouki Kimura, from a family of '''', founded the Okuribito Academy together with nurse and entrepreneur Kei Takamaru. It offers training in encoffining, embalming, and related practices. ==See also==