Pre-release reception When it was first announced, few details were revealed. Upon hearing about it,
IGN theorized that it was an Americanized version of
Puyo Puyo Sun with
Pokémon characters, similar to how ''
Kirby's Avalanche was a localization of Puyo Puyo. Nintendo Power gave it a perfect score, Nintendo Power
also listed Pokémon Puzzle Challenge
as the 13th best Game Boy/Game Boy Color video game, calling the gameplay only second in addictiveness to Tetris, ultimately giving the nod to this version of the gameplay over Tetris Attack'' because of a few extra features.
Game Informers Ben Reeves called it the 12th best Game Boy game. He noted that it beat out
Tetris Attack for this game's increased polish. ''Children's software & new media revue: Volume 9
called it "addictive", commenting that those who were not interested in the series would be fine, commenting that it "holds little similarity" to the Pokémon
franchise. IGN editor Craig Harris called the return of the Tetris Attack gameplay "welcome", commenting that it was "as fun and addictive as it ever was". However, he criticized its lack of a Puzzle Edit mode, a mode found in the Nintendo 64 counterpart game Pokémon Puzzle League''. He awarded it the Editor's Choice award. In a
Pokémon video game retrospective, fellow
IGN editor Lucas M. Thomas commented that while it didn't bring anything new to the
Tetris Attack gameplay, it being in a "new, Colorized portable version was enough".
GameSpot editor Frank Provo commented that it "does the
Pokémon license proud", calling it both "addictive" and praising its overall value.
GamePro gave it 4.5 stars out of five, awarding it their Editor's Choice award. William Schiffmann of the
Associated Press commented that while it doesn't "break any new ground" and the
Pokémon theme constitutes a "sales gimmick", fans of
Tetris would enjoy it. ==Notes==