Polo Grounds III Polo Grounds III was the stadium that made the name nationally famous. Built in 1890, it initially had a completely open outfield bounded by just the outer fence, but
bleachers were gradually added. By the early 1900s, some bleacher sections encroached on the field from the foul lines about halfway along left and right field. Additionally, there were a pair of "cigar box" bleachers on either side of the "
batter's eye" in center field. The expansive outfield was cut down somewhat by a rope fence behind which
carriages (and early
automobiles) were allowed to park. By 1910, bleachers enclosed the outfield, and the carriage ropes were gone. The hodge-podge approach to the bleacher construction formed a multi-faceted outfield area. There were a couple of gaps between some of the sections, and that would prove significant in 1911. Known as
Brotherhood Park when it opened in 1890, Polo Grounds III was the home of a
second New York Giants franchise in the
Players' League. The latter was a creation of Major League Baseball's first union, the Brotherhood of Professional Base-Ball Players. After failing to win concessions from National League owners, the Brotherhood founded its own league in 1890. The Players' League Giants built Brotherhood Park in the northern half of Coogan's Hollow, next door to Polo Grounds II, otherwise bounded by rail yards and the bluff. Brotherhood Park hosted its first game on April 19, 1890, the same day the National League's Giants played their first home game of the season. For the full 1890 season the two editions of the Giants were neighbors. When the teams played on the same day, fans in the upper decks could watch each other's games, and home run balls hit in one park might land on the other team's playing field. After the one season the Players' League folded, and the Brotherhood's members went back to the National League. The National League Giants then moved out of Polo Grounds II and into Brotherhood Park, which was larger. They took their stadium's name with them once again, turning Brotherhood Park into the new-new Polo Grounds. Between Polo Grounds II and III-IV, they would remain in Coogan's Hollow for 69 seasons.
Fire and reconstruction as Polo Grounds IV In the very early morning hours of Friday, April 14, 1911, a fire of uncertain origin swept through the stadium's horseshoe-shaped grandstand, consuming wood and leaving only steel uprights in place. The gaps between some sections of the stands saved a good portion of the outfield seating and the clubhouse from destruction. Giants owner
John T. Brush decided to rebuild the Polo Grounds with concrete and steel, renting
Hilltop Park from the Highlanders during reconstruction. Progress was sufficient to allow the stadium to reopen just 2½ months later, June 28, 1911, the date some baseball guides date the structure. As configured, it was the ninth
concrete-and-steel stadium in the Majors and fourth in the National League. Unfinished seating areas were rebuilt during the season while the games went on. The new structure stretched in roughly the same semicircle from the left field corner around home plate to the right field corner as prior but was extended into deep right-center field. The surviving wooden bleachers were retained basically as is, with gaps remaining on each side between the new
fireproof construction. The Giants rose from the ashes along with their ballpark, winning the National League pennant in 1911 (as they also would in 1912 and 1913). As evidenced from the World Series programs, the team renamed the new structure
Brush Stadium in honor of their then-owner John T. Brush, but the name did not stick, and by the late 1910s it was passé. The remaining old bleachers were demolished during the 1923 season when the permanent double-deck was extended around most of the rest of the field and new bleachers and clubhouse were constructed across center field. This construction gave the stadium its familiar horseshoe or bathtub style shape, as well as a new nickname, "The Bathtub". This version of the ballpark had its share of quirks. The "unofficial" distances (never marked on the wall) down the left and right field lines were respectively, but there was a overhang in left field, which often intercepted fly balls that would otherwise have been catchable and turned them into home runs. Contrasting with the short distances down the foul lines were the 450-foot distances to deepest left and right center (the gaps); the base of the straightaway centerfield clubhouse stood 483 feet from
home plate, up a 58-foot runway from the grandstand corners on either side of the clubhouse (these corners were themselves from home plate). The famous photo of
The catch made by
Willie Mays in the
1954 World Series against
Vic Wertz of the
Cleveland Indians occurred immediately in front of the "batter's eye", a metal screen atop the grandstand wall directly to the right of the centerfield runway. It would have been a home run in several other ballparks of the time as well as in most of today's modern ballparks. The
bullpens were actually in play, in the left and right center field gaps. The outfield sloped downward from the infield, and people in the dugouts often could only see the top half of the outfielders. The
New York Yankees sublet the Polo Grounds from the Giants during 1913–1922 after their lease on
Hilltop Park expired. After the 1922 season, the Yankees built
Yankee Stadium directly across the
Harlem River from the Polo Grounds, which spurred the Giants to expand their park to reach a comparable
seating capacity to stay competitive. Since nearly all the new seating was in the outfield, Yankee Stadium still had more desirable seats than did the Polo Grounds for watching baseball. However, the Polo Grounds became better suited for football due to the new seating placement. The Giants' first
night game at the stadium was played on May 24, 1940. The Polo Grounds was the site of one of the most iconic moments in baseball history – the historic
"Shot Heard 'Round the World" walk-off home run on October 3, 1951 that decided the hard-fought
National League pennant playoff series between the Giants and their cross-town rivals, the
Brooklyn Dodgers.
Deaths at the Polo Grounds in foreground, circa 1915. Note vacant lot, site of Manhattan Field. On August 16, 1920, Cleveland Indians shortstop
Ray Chapman was hit in the head by a pitch thrown by the Yankees'
Carl Mays. At the time, batters did not wear
helmets. Chapman died 12 hours after he was hit, at 4:30 a.m. on August 17. He remains the only player to die from an injury sustained in a Major League Baseball game. On July 4, 1950, Bernard Doyle, a resident of
Fairview, New Jersey, in his 50s, originally from
Dublin, Ireland, was struck and killed by a stray bullet while in his seat at the Polo Grounds. Doyle had brought a neighbor's son with him to see a
doubleheader between the Dodgers and the Giants. Doyle was killed about an hour prior to the start of the first game. A 14-year-old boy later confessed to having shot a
.45 caliber pistol into the air from his rooftop at 515 Edgecombe Avenue, located from where Doyle was seated.
Giants' final years The Polo Grounds' end was somewhat anticlimactic, especially compared to other "
Jewel Box" parks. Part of the problem was that the stadium was not well maintained from the late 1940s onward: while the baseball Giants owned
the stadium, the Coogan heirs still owned
the parcel of land on which it stood, while the neighborhood around the stadium had begun to go to seed in the late 1940s. These, along with other factors, combined to restrict ticket sales, even when the Giants were playing well. In 1954, for example, the baseball Giants drew only 1.1 million fans (compared to over two million for the
Milwaukee Braves) despite winning the
World Series. The football Giants left for Yankee Stadium across the Harlem River following the
1955 NFL season, and the baseball Giants' disastrous
1956 season – most of which they spent in last place before a late-season surge moved them up to sixth – caused a further decline on ticket sales. The Giants' 1956 attendance was less than half of that for the Giants' World Series-winning 1954 season, and also ranked last in Major League Baseball. Along with the departure of the football Giants and the consequential loss of their rent, this collapse of the baseball Giants' gate financially devastated franchise owner
Horace Stoneham, who was not nearly as wealthy as his fellow owners – the Giants were his sole source of income. To make matters worse, Stoneham was left with no money for stadium upkeep, and he was forced to lay off the stadium's maintenance staff in order to stay afloat. The stadium also had very little parking; its final form had opened two years after the
Model T was introduced. Due to the manner in which the stadium was designed, fans had to pour onto the field to exit via the center field gates, making for a problematic situation whenever attendance was anywhere near capacity. Frustrated with the Polo Grounds being obsolete and dilapidated, and with no maintenance staff or prospect of the stadium being renovated, Stoneham seriously considered having the Giants become tenants of the Yankees in the Bronx, or moving to a proposed stadium that would have been owned by the city. On September 18, 1963, 1,752 fans went to see the
New York Mets play their last game at the Polo Grounds against the
Philadelphia Phillies with a 5–1 Philadelphia win. The game's highlights were later shown on
Universal-International Newsreel. On October 12, the Polo Grounds played host to one last exhibition contest, as Latin American All-Stars of the National League, managed by
Roberto Clemente and behind the pitching of
Juan Marichal and
Al McBean, defeated
Hector Lopez's AL Stars, 5–2. The final sporting event played at the Polo Grounds was on December 14, 1963 when the now renamed AFL team New York Jets lost to the Buffalo Bills 19–10. In the 1992 book
The Gospel According to Casey, by Ira Berkow and Jim Kaplan, it is reported (p. 62) that in 1963, Mets manager
Casey Stengel, who had bittersweet memories of his playing days at the Polo Grounds, had this to say during a rough outing to pitcher
Tracy Stallard, whose greatest claim to fame had been giving up
Roger Maris' 61st homer in 1961: "At the end of this season, they're gonna tear this joint down. The way you're pitchin', the right field section will be gone already!"
Demolition The final iteration of the Polo Grounds was demolished in 1964, The site is now home to the
Polo Grounds Towers, a public housing project opened in 1968, and managed by the New York City Housing Authority. ==Sports other than baseball==