Ratings In its original American broadcast on February 2, 2014, "Prince" was viewed by 26.3 million viewers, according to
Nielsen Media Research, making it the most watched-episode of
New Girl. The episode drew an 11.4 rating in adults between the ages of 18 and 49. In contrast, the average viewership of an episode in the
third season of
New Girl, excluding "Prince", was 3.30 million. "Prince" posted a 42 percent increase in adults 18–49, and a 23 percent increase in viewers over the previous year's post-Super Bowl episode of
Elementary.
New Girl became the highest rated scripted entertainment telecast on television in three years, since Fox's post-Super Bowl episode of
Glee, "
The Sue Sylvester Shuffle". As expected,
New Girl benefited from following the broadcast of Super Bowl XLVIII, which was seen by 112.19 million average viewers, making it the most watched Super Bowl in history at the time. The re-broadcast earned 1.78 million viewers, according to Nielsen Media Research. It drew a 0.7/2 rating/share in adults between the ages of 18 and 49.
Critical response The episode's plot received mixed reviews from television critics, but Prince's guest appearance was well received. Marc Hogan of
Spin found the humour around "characters inexplicably fainting" to be "a bit too FOX sitcom-y", but he called Prince's appearance "pure gold". Chris Morgan of
Paste felt that while the episode "certainly wasn't the greatest", it was "a strange, fabulous moment in the history of the series, and also a testament to the kind of life Prince chose to live."
TVLine's Kimberly Roots admitted that she did not laugh once during the episode, which she said was "not
New Girl's sharpest". Similarly,
IGN UK's Max Nicholson thought some elements of the episode were "a stretch" and found the plot to be "a little tedious". But he added that Nick and Jess's storyline was "made much more enjoyable" with the addition of Prince and "a few asides" from the other lead characters. He did not think the conflict between Nick and Jess was believable enough, saying "I was just frustrated because the stakes in this episode were staggeringly low. Nothing seemed to really matter to anyone." Likewise, Erik Adams of
The A.V. Club, who gave the episode a B+ score called it "very, very funny". He felt Prince improved the plot and added that his involvement in Nick and Jess's romance was "a new spin on a storyline that countless other TV shows and movies have tried out." Adams also praised the show's editorial team for the montage. ==References==