Background Seven churchmen, four members from other nearby Reformed Dutch Churches, and three
Presbyterians organized the Flushing congregation, and on May 20, 1842, formed the Flushing Reformed Dutch Church. Prior to the church's founding, parishioners either attended at the churches at
Jamaica or Newtown, or with the Presbyterians worshipping at
Saint George's. The church was formally incorporated the following year, in 1843, as the “Protestant Reformed Dutch Church of Flushing.” The congregation erected the church at the corner of Prince and Washington (now 37th Avenue) streets. The cornerstone and foundation stones for the first church building were quarried from Blackwell's (Roosevelt) Island, and were laid in August 1843. Later, some of those same stones were salvaged to build a fireplace in the current church building. By the 1870s, the Reformed Dutch Church had increased in membership and plans were made to move farther away from the overpopulated center of town. In 1873, a large undeveloped lot (approx. ) was acquired from local landowner Mary B. Parsons. Located at the northeast corner of Bowne and Amity streets (now Roosevelt Avenue), the lot was described at the time as “perhaps the best site in Flushing for a church.” In 1877, a parsonage was built on the southeastern portion of the lot, but it would be another 20 years before funds were secured for construction of the church itself. In December 1890, Reverend James Demarest (1832–1913), a distinguished cleric within the Reformed Church of America Synod of New York, arrived to take the post as pastor and served until 1897. In 1899 the parsonage was sold and debts incurred during construction of the church were due. In 1907 a new parsonage was added to the church holdings at 37-16 Parsons Boulevard.
Construction The church was built by Edward Richardson, who laid the cornerstone on October 10, 1891. The first recorded meetings held there were Sunday Services in May 1892. The church was formally dedicated six months later on November 6, 1892. It seated approximately 700 people and was taller and larger than the building it replaced. ==Architecture==