Box office The Captive earned a total of $1 million domestically and another $1 million outside of Canada. The film's
Metacritic score is 36 out of 100 based on 20 reviews, indicating "generally unfavorable reviews". Sam Adams remarked that many critics who watched the premiere compared it unfavourably with
Denis Villeneuve's
Prisoners, released a year earlier, but that "the harshest comparisons" were to Egoyan's past films, evidence of a "precipitous downward slide", referencing the director's recent ''
Devil's Knot, which opened the week before "to resoundingly negative reviews." Peter Bradshaw from The Guardian commented, "it looks worryingly as if Egoyan has taken a serious issue and burdened it to breaking point and beyond with his own indulgent, naïve and exploitative fantasies". Steven Zeitchik of the Los Angeles Times'' compliments moments when the film "hints at emotions and mysteries with a delightful subtlety for a while", but remarks that it includes "some wild plots and conspiracies that wouldn't be out of place in the most fantastical spy novel". Alex Heeney praised the film's cinematography but faulted the script: "it tries to balance six protagonists who should be dealing with complicated emotions, while also hitting all the marks of a thriller. Egoyan does some top notch directing to keep the tension heightened, making the film work as a genre piece. The constant suspense can keep you from thinking too hard about the vacuousness of the characters, making it an OK film that’s only worth seeing once. It’s a shame because there are a lot of good ideas here, and it’s a chilling concept that deserves further explanation."
Robbie Collin of
The Telegraph gave the film a very positive review, calling it Atom Egoyan's best film since
The Sweet Hereafter. Jonathan Romney, writing for
Screen Daily, said Egoyan was "visibly at ease" with the themes of online child pornography, and that the film managed to "unsettle, and to convey emotional tremors even while playing its games"." Romney expected that the film's narrative and stylistic elegance as well as a strong cast would make it the director's most widely appreciated film for some time, while conceding that "some viewers may object on grounds of taste to such a ludic - and to a degree, coolly detached - entertainment being drawn from such sombre subject matter." In ''
Maclean's, a Canadian critic who also found fault with the film nevertheless concluded along with their colleagues that "Cannes had no business leading The Captive'' to slaughter in the main competition in the first place... Egoyan's new film is clearly miscast on that lofty altar, and the festival's programmers did everyone—especially Egoyan—a gross disservice by placing it there." Reviewing the film for
RogerEbert.com months later, Scout Tafoya gave it 3 stars out of 4, praising the cinematography,
sound design, and performances, and suggested that sometimes, an "audience rejecting your work might be a sign that you've hit a nerve and produced something they can’t process." Egoyan also suggested that
The Captive had gained fresh resonance in the light of revelations about the American financier and sexual predator
Jeffrey Epstein: "In terms of this incredible crazy cabal that we found out about his life after this, it makes more sense now." Writing for
Netflix Life during the film's rise in popularity on the streaming service in 2026, Crystal George suggests that the film may have been dismissed too quickly by its harshest critics, that its slow, methodical approach demands patience, but also "creates an atmosphere of tension and dread." Rather than offer "easy answers or comforting resolutions", it forces viewers to sit with the anguish of its characters. That's the grief, the guilt, and the desperate hope that maybe, somehow, the truth will lead to redemption. That emotional weight is precisely what makes the film so haunting." == References ==