•
Kitty Kallen – for her album
Honky Tonk Angel, Country Songs with a City Flavor (1961). •
Bobby Vee – for his album
Take Good Care of My Baby (1962). •
Johnnie Ray – included in the 5-CD
Bear Family Records set
Yes Tonight Josephine. •
Patti Page – included in the compilation album
From Nashville to L.A.: Lost Columbia Masters 1962–1969 (2013). •
Skeeter Davis released her tribute album
Skeeter Davis Sings Buddy Holly (1967) featuring the song. •
Dean Martin –
For the Good Times (1971). • The
Dave Clark Five covered this song on their 1971 album,
The Dave Clark Five Play Good Old Rock & Roll. •
Anne Murray did a cover of the song on her album
New Kind of Feeling (1979). •
Peter Skellern –
Still Magic (1980). •
Connie Francis released her tribute album
With Love to Buddy featuring the song in 1996. •
Status Quo on their album ''
Don't Stop'' in 1996. • In 1996,
Hank Marvin did an instrumental of the song on
Hank Plays Holly. • Australian blues and root band
The Revelators covered the song on their 2000 album,
The Adventures of The Amazing Revelators. •
Don McLean on his live double album
Starry Starry Night in 2001. •
Robert Wyatt included a piano based instrumental version on his 2003 album,
Cuckooland. • Eric Idle contributed a
Spike Jones-esque cover of "Raining in My Heart" for the tribute album,
Listen to Me: Buddy Holly released in September 2011. ==In popular culture==