2015 appointment In May 2015, Walker elevated Bradley to the
Wisconsin Court of Appeals to fill a vacancy caused by the death of Judge
Ralph Adam Fine. After the death of Justice
N. Patrick Crooks in 2015, Bradley was appointed by Walker to serve as a justice of the Wisconsin Supreme Court for the remainder of Crooks' term.
Elections 2016 After Crooks' death, Bradley,
JoAnne Kloppenburg (who narrowly lost a race for the Wisconsin Supreme Court in 2011), and
Joe Donald each announced their candidacy for the seat in the 2016 election. In the February 16 primary, Bradley edged Kloppenburg 44.7–43.2%, moving the two of them on to the general election in an even race. Bradley's
homophobic writings as an undergraduate, published in 1992 in
Marquette University's student newspaper, stirred controversy during the race. She had written
letters to the editor and a column for the
Marquette Tribune, in which she stated she held no sympathy for AIDS patients because they were "degenerates" who had effectively chosen to kill themselves. She also referred to gay people as "queers". She called Americans who voted for
Bill Clinton "either totally stupid or entirely evil". She blasted supporters of abortion as murderers, and compared abortion to the Holocaust and slavery. Bradley apologized for her student writings in 2016, shortly after the controversy arose. Pre-election polls showed Bradley with a slight lead, but with a significant portion of the electorate still undecided. She was projected as the winner by a 53–47% margin on election night, and she quoted
Winston Churchill at the end of her victory speech: "There is nothing more exhilarating than being shot at without result."
2026 On April 5, 2025, Bradley announced that she planned to seek re-election to the court in 2026. On August 29, 2025, after months of speculation due to nonexistent fundraising, Bradley announced that she has reversed her previous decision and would no longer seek reelection.
Tenure In June 2019, Bradley wrote the majority opinion for the Wisconsin Supreme Court when conservatives on the court upheld a series of laws, passed by the Republican-led Wisconsin legislature and Republican Governor Scott Walker during a
lame-duck session, limiting the powers of the incoming Democratic Governor (
Tony Evers) and Attorney General (
Josh Kaul). During the
COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, she dissented from a Wisconsin Supreme Court decision ordering the postponement of jury trials and the suspension of in-person court proceedings for public health reasons. In April 2020, during the pandemic, she joined the conservative majority on the Wisconsin Supreme Court in striking down Governor Evers' order to postpone an April 7 Wisconsin election due to the public health risks of the coronavirus. She voted in person on April 2, although casting a ballot in person before the date of the election is considered an
absentee vote in Wisconsin. Examination of Justice Bradley's voting record demonstrates that she voted in person on Election Day in 4 of the 5 previous elections. In May 2020, she compared the stay-at-home orders to the
internment of Japanese-Americans during World War II, and labeled them "tyrannic". In November 2020, while COVID-19 cases were surging in Wisconsin, she was in the Wisconsin Supreme Court's conservative majority which prevented the City of Racine Public Health Department from ordering school closures. In the fallout of the 2020 presidential election, Bradley issued a dissenting minority opinion in the
unsuccessful case brought by the
Trump campaign to overturn the
2020 presidential election results in Wisconsin. While agreeing with at least some of the Trump campaign's allegations, none of the dissenting judges (including Bradley) would say what relief they thought should be given to Trump's campaign; instead, they merely agreed that Trump was right. Bradley's dissent called the majority's decision not to overturn the election "an indelible stain" that would cause "significant harm to the rule of law". In 2021, Bradley was the sole judge on the Wisconsin Supreme Court to rule in favor of a man who argued that his
Second Amendment rights allowed him to brandish firearms while intoxicated and arguing with his roommates. Bradley said that the conviction against the man "erodes a fundamental freedom". In the 2022 decision
Teigen v. Wisconsin Election Commission, which held that
ballot drop boxes are illegal under Wisconsin statutes, Bradley wrote "If elections are conducted outside of the law, the people have not conferred their consent on the government. Such elections are unlawful and their results are illegitimate."
Teigen was ultimately overturned by the Wisconsin Supreme Court on July 5, 2024, with Bradley authoring the
dissenting opinion. ==Personal life==