's performance as Arthur Morgan received praise from several
gaming publications and
awards ceremonies.|alt=Roger Clark The character of Arthur Morgan received critical acclaim.
Giant Bombs Alex Navarro wrote that the thoughtful portrayal of Arthur's internal conflicts possessed humanity often lacking in Rockstar's other games.
LevelSkips Kyle Atwood called him a "character of tragedy and, most importantly, humanity".
Kotakus Kirk Hamilton opined that Arthur initially seemed unremarkable but became more intriguing because of Clark's performance.
Ars Technicas Daniel Starkey felt that, while Arthur's story can be considered "poignant and memorable", some may see it as a typical tale about a bad man' who isn't necessarily in control".
GamesRadar+s Tom Power believed the account of Arthur's life in
Red Dead Redemption 2 reflected a
Shakespearean tragedy, with various chapters representing the
five stages of grief.
Electronic Gaming Monthlys Nick Plessas found his journey "far more redeeming" than John Marston's in
Red Dead Redemption, noting Arthur's shortcomings evoked a sense of sympathy.
Game Informers Javy Gwaltney echoed this sentiment, describing the arc as a "fantastic take on
memento mori and how ruthlessly messy and complex redemption can be". Conversely,
Eurogamers Martin Robinson considered Arthur less compelling than John, thus confusing his experience.
The Guardians Paul Walker-Emig thought Arthur's journal made him appear "like a real person with his own inner life, rather than a puppet who does our bidding", and
The Mary Sues Madeline Carpou lauded the journal for demonstrating Arthur's sensitive personality.
The New York Timess Peter Suderman felt the player connected with Arthur "because his choices are, in fact, your own", and
Pastes Holly Green respected Arthur's awareness of his own faults and misdeeds.
Digital Spys Laurence Mozafari submitted that Arthur perfectly encapsulated the feeling of the Old West.
VentureBeats
Dean Takahashi praised Clark's contribution for adding immersion to the game and depth to his character.
IGNs Luke Reilly hailed Arthur's voice as having an "infectious authenticity", and
Destructoids Noelle Warner found it made him a "quintessential southern American country boy". For his role, Clark won Best Performance at
the Game Awards 2018, and was a runner-up for the same category at
PlayStation Blog; he also received nominations at the
15th British Academy Games Awards,
NAVGTR Awards, and
New York Game Awards. Arthur was nominated at the
22nd Annual D.I.C.E. Awards and
Italian Video Game Awards. In November 2021,
GamesRadar+ ranked Arthur 29th on its list of iconic video game characters, citing the character's ability to "bring a nourishing sense of humanity to almost everything he does". In May 2022,
GamingBolt named Arthur the best video game protagonist of all time, praising the writing, Clark's performance, and the character's personal narrative and relationships. In 2024, Arthur was ranked the eleventh most iconic game character in a poll with over 4,000 respondents by
BAFTA. == References ==