Meat Loaf version Upon the single release,
Larry Flick from
Billboard magazine wrote, "There were moments when it seemed like '
I'd Do Anything for Love' would never cool off. Its follow-up from the massive comeback set,
Bat Out of Hell 2: Back into Hell, is an appropriately grand and cinematic rocker that places Mr. Loafs aching
tenor amid rushes of choir vocals, tinkling piano lines, and chugging rhythm guitars. Diehards undoubtedly will draw comparisons to producer Jim Steinman's own rendition of the tune, while novice fans will happily snarl down this hit-bound version." Alan Jones from
Music Week gave it four out of five, saying, "Trimmed to just over five minutes, this long-awaited follow-up to 'I'd Do Anything for Love' is lighter than its chart-topping predecessor, but no less commercial. Radio is already leaping aboard, and a Top 10 placing is a certainty, though another number one seems out of reach, even though there's a 13-minute live version of 'l'd Do Anything...' included." Pan-European magazine
Music & Media wrote, "The carnivore rocker cuts another slice from the favoured
Bat Out of Hell II loaf. Fewer drama and tempo changes mark the differences with the first single." ==Music videos==