Thornton's recording of "Hound Dog" is credited with "helping to spur the evolution of black R&B into
rock music". Leiber regarded the original recording by the 350-pound "blues belter" Big Mama Thornton as his favorite version, In 1992, Leiber and Stoller recalled that during the rehearsal, Thornton sang the song as a ballad. Leiber said that this was not the way they planned and sang it for her, with Stoller on piano, as an example of the concept. Thornton agreed to try their recommendation. According to Maureen Mahon, a music professor at
New York University, Thornton's version is "an important [part of the] beginning of
rock-and-roll, especially in its use of the guitar as the key instrument".
Recording Thornton recorded "Hound Dog" at
Radio Recorders Annex in Los Angeles on August 13, 1952, the day after its composition. It subsequently became her biggest hit. According to
Hound Dog: The Leiber and Stoller Autobiography, Thornton's "Hound Dog" was the first record that Leiber and Stoller produced themselves, taking over from bandleader Johnny Otis. Said Stoller: Otis played drums on the recording, replacing Ledard "Kansas City" Bell. As Otis was still signed exclusively to
Federal Records, a subsidiary of
Syd Nathan's
King Records as "Kansas City Bill" or perhaps with
Mercury Records at this time, Otis used the
pseudonym "Kansas City Bill" (after his drummer "Kansas City" Bell) on this record. Therefore, Otis, Louisiana blues guitarist
Pete "Guitar" Lewis, and Puerto Rican bass player Mario Delagarde (some sources say erroneously it was Albert Winston) are listed as "Kansas City Bill & Orchestra" on the Peacock record labels. During the rehearsal, Leiber objected to Thornton's vocal approach, as she was
crooning the lyrics rather than
belting them out. Although intimidated by her size and facial scarring, Leiber protested, to which Thornton responded with an icy glare and told him, White boy, don't you be tellin' me how to sing the blues. After this exchange, Leiber sang the song himself to demonstrate how they wanted it done. Thornton interacts constantly in a
call and response fashion during a one-minute long guitar "solo" by Lewis. These verbal interjections, sometimes called "blues talk", are common in blues music. Years later Thornton helped launch a controversy over "Hound Dog", claiming to have written it. When questioned further on the matter, Thornton explained that, while the song had been composed by Leiber and Stoller, she had transformed it: "They gave me the words, but I changed it around and did it my way". In his book
Race, Rock, and Elvis, Michael T. Bertrand says that Thornton's explanation "ingenuously stresses artist interpretation as the sole yardstick with which to measure authenticity". Thornton recorded two takes of the song, and the second take was released.
Habanera and
mambo elements can be found in this recording. Puerto Rican bass player Mario Delagarde is credited with adding "a
jazz-based rhythm". its "sounds range from the gravelly beginning of several phrases, to her spoken and howled interpolations, and the ending with dog sounds from the band." According to Maureen Mahon: On September 9, 1952, the copyright application for "Hound Dog" was lodged. On the application the words and music are attributed to Thornton and recording executive
Don Robey, with the copyright claimants listed as: "Murphy L. Robey (W) & Willie Mae Thornton (A)." It was renewed subsequently on May 13, 1980, with the same details.
Release and reception In late February 1953, "Hound Dog" was released by Peacock (Peacock 1612), Thornton recalled later that she learned her record was in circulation while she was on her way to a performance with the Johnny Otis Orchestra during this tour in Dayton, Ohio. "I was going to the theater and I just turned the radio on in the car and the man said, 'Here's a record that's going nationwide: 'Hound Dog' by Willie Mae Thornton.' I said, 'That's me!' [laughs] I hadn't heard the record in so long. So when we get to the theater they was blasting it. You could hear it from the theater, from the loudspeaker. They were just playing 'Hound Dog' all over the theater. So I goes up in the operating room, I say, 'Do you mind playing that again?' 'Cause I hadn't heard the record in so long I forgot the words myself. So I stood there while he was playing it, listening to it. So that evening I sang it on the show, and everybody went for it. 'Hound Dog' just took off like a jet." On March 7, 1953, "Hound Dog" was advertised in
Billboard, and reviewed positively on March 14, 1953, as a new record to watch, described as "a wild and exciting
rhumba blues" with "infectious backing that rocks all the way". According to
Johnny Ace biographer James M. Salem, "The rawness of the sound combined with the overt sexuality of the lyric made 'Hound Dog' an immediate smash hit in urban black America from late March to the middle of July 1953." "Hound Dog" took off immediately and looked like a national hit record.
Rufus Thomas quickly recorded an answer song called "Bear Cat" on
Sun 181. Thornton's record was such a big seller that Peacock Records had three new pressing plants running full-time to try and keep up with demand. Debuting in the charts on March 28, 1953, seven of them at number one. By April 30, 1953,
Cash Box magazine listed the song as "the nation's top-selling blues record", and it topped the charts in New York, Chicago, New Orleans, San Francisco, Newark, Memphis, Dallas, Cincinnati, St. Louis, and Los Angeles. "By mid summer, it is obvious that "Hound Dog" will be the biggest seller in the history of Peacock Records." Don Robey estimated that Thornton's version of "Hound Dog" sold between 500,000 and 750,000 copies, and would have sold more had its sales not been diluted by an abundance of cover versions and "
answer songs". However, despite its success, neither the composers nor artist were compensated well for their efforts. According to Stoller, "Big Mama's 'Hound Dog' went to number one, sold a million copies, and did nothing for our bank statements. We were getting screwed." and publishing company, Quintet Music. Similarly, Thornton stated: "That song sold over two million records. I got one check for $500 and never saw another." In 1984, she told
Rolling Stone, "Didn't get no money from them at all. Everybody livin' in a house but me. I'm just livin."
Re-releases By July 1956, "the rock 'n roll age was upon the world, and as the new sensation Elvis Presley recorded "Hound Dog" to international acclaim, Peacock re-released Thornton's original" but it failed to chart. In Australia and New Zealand, Prestige Records (founded in Auckland by 17 year-old
Phil Warren and Bruce Henderson) released the same record on licence in 1956 (Prestige PSP-1004), but the composition is credited to Robey-Thornton-Leiber-Stoller. By early 1957, "Willie Mae Thornton is seen as one who is out of the rock /
pop mainstream and so her affiliation with Peacock Records ends... Thornton continues to make personal appearances and is always remembered for her original version of "Hound Dog" which gets a spate of airplay during the summer of 1958 which leads to another re-release of the original."
Awards and Accolades • In 1990, it was ranked No. 36 on
Rolling Stone's "Fifty Essential Recordings from the Fifties" (1990) • In February 2013, Thornton's recording of "Hound Dog" was inducted into
Grammy Hall of Fame. • Thornton's recording of "Hound Dog" is listed as one of the
Rock and Roll Hall of Fame's "500 Songs That Shaped Rock and Roll" in April 2013. • In 2017, Thornton's recording of "Hound Dog" was selected for preservation in the
National Recording Registry by the
Library of Congress as being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant". • The original version was ranked No. 318 on the 2021 edition of "Top 500 Songs of All Time" by
Rolling Stone Magazine.
Responses (1953–1955) Cover versions Thornton's "Hound Dog" was so popular that it spawned at least ten cover versions of the original before Elvis Presley recorded it in July 1956. in its review on April 11, 1953,
Billboard opined: "It fails to build the same excitement of the original." Within a month of the release of Thornton's "Hound Dog", the following six country cover versions of the song—all credited erroneously to Leiber-Stoller (or )-Otis—were released on several different labels by white artists: (actually
Henry D. Haynes on vocals, with his
Homer and Jethro partner
Kenneth C. Burns on mandolin, with
Chet Atkins on
lead guitar, Charles Green on bass, and
Jerry Byrd on
steel guitar), recorded a
rockabilly boogie or
hillbilly country-western version on March 20, 1953, in New York City. After the success of
Patti Page's version of the
Bob Merrill-penned "
(How Much Is) That Doggie in the Window?", as Homer and Jethro they recorded a parody version, "(How Much Is) That Hound Dog in the Window" (RCA Victor 47–5280) in March that went to number two on the US
Country charts, and number 17 on the
Billboard national charts.
Billboard noted: "By coincidence or intent, the use of 'hound dog' also recognizes the top r&b record of the moment." After Elvis Presley released his version of "Hound Dog" in 1956, by early November, Homer & Jethro released a parody version, "Houn' Dawg" (RCA Victor 6706). • Billy Starr (
Imperial 8186) This version is described as "a
juke joint-honed blend of country and pre-rockabilly raunch". • Eddie Hazelwood (Intro 6069)
Billboard described her recording: "She sings it well, shouting out the lyrics with occasional excitement, tho without the power the tune needs." • Former
Texas Playboy band Western swing vocalist
Tommy Duncan and the Miller Bros. (Intro 6071) Duncan's version is described as "a smoother, jazzy reading featuring fine guitar and piano contributions". • Cleve Jackson (Jackson Cleveland Toombs) & His Hound Dogs (
Herald 6000), On February 24, 1954,
The Cozy Cole All Stars recorded an instrumental version, "Hound Dog Special" (MGM 11794), a " of Willie Mae Thornton's" version. Bass player Al Rex, who joined
Bill Haley and His Comets in the fall of 1955, told of performing the song when given the spotlight at live performances. "I used to do 'Hound Dog.' Haley would get mad at me if I'd do that. This was even before Presley did it. Haley didn't like those guys from Philadelphia that wrote the song."
Answers and Parodies By the end of 1953, at least six "answer songs" that responded to 'Big Mama' Thornton's original version of "Hound Dog" were released.
"Bear Cat" (1953) The first and most popular answer song to "Hound Dog" was "Bear Cat (The Answer To Hound Dog)" (Sun 101), recorded at
Sun Studios at 706 Union Avenue, Memphis, Tennessee on March 8, 1953, just two weeks after Thornton's original version was released, and even before a review of "Hound Dog" had been published in
Billboard. "Bear Cat" had new lyrics written by Sun Records founder
Sam Phillips, According to Phillips' biographer
Peter Guralnick: :Sam was knocked out by Big Mama Thornton's "Hound Dog" the first time he heard it. Performed with ripsaw gusto by the singer... and modified by a delicate
Latin-flavored "rhumba-
boogie" beat, the record struck a communal chord somewhere between low comedy and bedrock truth. It totally tickled Sam on both levels. "I said, my God, it's so true. You ain't nothing but a hound dog. You ain't met your responsibilities. You didn't go to work like you [should]." And it gave him an immediate idea for a follow-up – from the ''man's'' point of view... "Bear Cat", "[i]n the time-honored tradition of answer songs, was a virtual carbon copy of "Hound Dog" with lyrics, chord progressions, and rhythmic structure all patterned directly on the original. Looking for a suitable man to record this song, Phillips selected part-time local
WDIA disk jockey Rufus Thomas, who adopted the nickname, "Rufus 'Hound Dog' Thomas" for this recording. "With his gruff
Louis Armstrong-influenced voice, quick wit, and eye-popping antics, he was the perfect candidate to reply to the harsh accusations Big Mama Thornton had thrown out in her song, this time leveling them at a 'bossy woman'". Within two weeks, "Bear Cat" (Sun 181) was in stores, prompting
Billboard to describe it on March 28 as "the fastest answer song to hit the market". More than 5,000 copies were ordered in the first days by distributors, and by mid-April it had charted nationally, eventually reaching number three on the R&B charts. a copyright-infringement suit ensued that nearly bankrupted Phillips' record label.
Other Answer Records In the months after the release of "Hound Dog" and "Bear Cat", a spate of answer records followed: • On March 18, Blues shouter Roy Brown recorded "Mr. Hound Dog's in Town" for King Records (45–4627). While it had the same melody and many of the same lyrics as the original, Brown is credited as the sole writer. Despite the threat of legal action, • Vocalist Charlie Gore and guitarist Louis Innis recorded "(You Ain't Nothin' But a Female) Hound Dog" (King 45–1212) for King Records on March 22. This song was credited to Innis, Lois Mann (a pseudonym of King Records owner
Syd Nathan, the latter his wife's maiden name), and Johnny Otis. • At the request of
Leonard Chess, Blues guitarist
John Brim wrote an answer song called "Rattlesnake" for
Chess Records'
Checker subsidiary. "Rattlesnake" and "It Was a Dream" were backed by
Little Walter on
blues harp;
Willie Dixon on string bass;
Fred Below on drums; and
Louis and Dave Myers on guitar. However, when Don Robey threatened an injunction against Sun Records for the similar "Bear Cat", Leonard and
Phil Chess, decided not to release "Rattlesnake" at that time. and the backing musicians credited as "his Stompers". •
Jake Porter's Combo Records released "Real Gone Hound Dog" (Combo 25), "an obscure 'answer' record to 'Hound Dog'", by
Chuck Higgins and His Mellotones' with a vocal by Higgins' brother "
Daddy Cleanhead". The composition was credited to Higgins and Porter (as V. Haven). • "Call Me a Hound Dog", written by
Bob Geddins, in which the hound dog states his case, was recorded by Blues singer
Jimmy Wilson (as Jimmie Wilson) and His All Stars (with Hal "King" Solomon on piano) and released by Geddins' Big Town Records in May 1953 (Big Town Records 103). The review in the May 23 edition of
Billboard describes this song as "the latest, and possibly the last in the long line of answers to 'Hound Dog', featuring Jimmy Wilson singing the tune okay style. Ork backs him in a blues manner but they could have added a stronger beat." • Former
Our Gang child actor
Eugene Jackson and actress
Juanita Moore (backed by the Eugene Jackson Trio and All Stars) also recorded "You Call Me a Hound Dog" about this time which was released on
John Dolphin's
Recorded In Hollywood label (421A). • "New Hound Dog" (Big Town 116) by
Frank "Dual Trumpeter" Motley and His Motley Crew, with vocals provided by
Curley Bridges was recorded in October 1954 Motley is credited as the sole composer, and "King" Herbert Whitaker plays tenor saxophone. This song is described as "the first rocking rearrangement of 'Hound Dog'". When the dust settled, the publishing for "Hound Dog" (in all variations) remained with Lion, and writing credit with Leiber and Stoller. In April 1954,
Billboards Rolontz summed up the events thusly: "The year 1953 saw an important precedent set in regard to answer tunes… since the 'Hound Dog' decision, few record firms have attempted to 'answer' smash hits by other companies by using same tune with different lyrics."
"Rip offs" Two records were released that were neither cover versions of nor answers to Thornton's release, yet used a similar melody without any attribution to Leiber and Stoller. The first was
Smiley Lewis's "Play Girl", credited to
D. Bartholomew and released by the Imperial Records label (Imperial 45–5234) by the end of March 1953. Described as a "stomping uptempo boogie rocker", it began: "You ain't nothin' but a Play Girl / Staying out all night long". In April 1955,
female impersonator Jesse "Big 'Tiny'" Kennedy recorded "Country Boy" accompanied by His Orchestra that was released by RCA's
Groove Records (Groove 4G-0106) by May 21. While credited solely to Kennedy, this song has a similar melody to "Hound Dog": "'Country Boy' has a deceptively slouching flip on the 'Hound Dog' motif – this time with Tiny proclaiming proudly that he 'ain't nothing but a country boy'". In the early 1970s, Robert Loers, owner of Dutch label Redita Records, found a song with the same melody as "Hound Dog" called "(You Ain't Nuttin' But a) Juicehead" on an anonymous
acetate at
Select-o-Hits, the Memphis distributorship owned by Sam Phillips' brother, Tom, where Sun artifacts were stored. ==Freddie Bell and the Bellboys' versions (1955–1956)==