Caren Myers from
Melody Maker named the song "Single of the Week", writing that it "occupies a smaller, more intimate space, delicately picking a path with mandolins and acoustic guitars, soothed by the mournful sweep of a string section. Deceptive echoes of '
World Leader Pretend' dissolve on second listen as the song wraps itself around the impossibility of communication with glancing but painful accuracy. Stipe's writing is getting sparser and more intense, riddled with oblique insights but unwilling to point out where. This is R.E.M. at their most tender and unsettling, Stipe's careworn voice filled with inexplicable sadness, but as warm and familiar as ever." A reviewer from
Music & Media wrote: "Hearing such a beautiful song with a striking mandolin arrangement, provides an ample religious substitute." Terry Staunton from
NME found that it "is likely to be read as self-reflection on R.E.M.'s position in the worldwide musical scheme of things, doubt and discomfort at the prospect of unwanted disciples". Parry Gettelman from
Orlando Sentinel wrote that R.E.M. had returned to its "trademark jangle", and that "Stipe touches again on what seems to be ambivalence about his role as a pop star, and about the need to communicate with an audience".
David Fricke from
Rolling Stone felt that "there is melancholy in the air: in the doleful strings and teardrop mandolin".
Celia Farber from
Spin praised it as "a gorgeous, gorgeous song" and said "I actually get a hot/cold flash and have to play the song about 30 more times" when she hears the opening lyrics. "Losing My Religion" placed second in the
Village Voice Pazz & Jop annual critics' poll, behind
Nirvana's "
Smells Like Teen Spirit". At the
1992 Grammy Awards, it earned several nominations, including Record of the Year and Song of the Year, and won for
Best Pop Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocals and
Best Short Form Music Video. In 2007, VH1 named it the ninth-best song of the 90s, and in 2009,
Blender ranked it No. 79 on its list of the "500 Greatest Songs Since You Were Born". The
Rock and Roll Hall of Fame included it in its 2004 list of "500 Songs that Shaped Rock and Roll". In 2004,
Rolling Stone listed "Losing My Religion" at No. 169 on its list of the "
500 Greatest Songs of All Time", writing that "never before had Michael Stipe sounded so vulnerable, yearning, and articulate". It ranked it at No. 112 in its updated 2024 list. ==Personnel==