Cleveland Indians Colavito made his MLB debut on September 10, for the Cleveland Indians. In , he started the season playing in the
Pacific Coast League, once showing off his throwing arm by hurling a ball over the center-field wall, from home plate. In July, he returned to the Indians. He finished the season
batting .276 with 21 home runs, and was tied for runner-up in the AL
Rookie of the Year voting. In , he batted .252 with 25 home runs. In , Colavito, now wearing number 6, In , Colavito hit 42 home runs and became the first Indians player to have two consecutive 40-HR seasons; he tied
Harmon Killebrew for the AL lead that season (was one short of
Al Rosen's club record) and was the AL leader in
extra-base hits (66) and
total bases (301). On June 10, at
Baltimore Orioles' cavernous
Memorial Stadium, he became the second player in AL history to hit four consecutive
home runs in a nine-inning game;
Lou Gehrig hit four in . In an interview in 2021, Colavito called the game the highlight of his career. He was selected for both of the All-Star Games held for the first time that season and homered in Game 2 (two All-Star games were held annually in 1959 through ). In the AL pennant race that year, the Indians finished second, five games behind the
Chicago White Sox. This was the closest he would come to a title until 1967. He also finished fourth in the MVP vote. Colavito would hit 30-plus home runs for seven seasons, establishing himself as a consistent power hitter. He also was an excellent outfielder with a very strong arm despite being
flat-footed.
Detroit Tigers On April 17, , Indians
general manager Frank Lane unexpectedly traded him to the
Detroit Tigers for
Harvey Kuenn (the 1959 AL batting champion, having hit .353) just two days before the opening day of the season in Cleveland against the Tigers. The Tigers played Colavito in right field because of his strong throwing arm, moving
Al Kaline to center field that season. Colavito hit .249 with 35 home runs and 87 RBI. In , Colavito hit .290 with a career-high 45 home runs, 140 RBI, and 129
runs scored. Detroit led the Major Leagues in scoring, and he placed eighth in the MVP race. Colavito was switched from right field to left field for the Tigers, and Kaline was reestablished in right field. Colavito was selected for both All-Star Games again and homered in Game 2. During a doubleheader that season against the
Washington Senators at
Griffith Stadium, he hit 4 home runs, 3 in Game 2.
Detroit Free Press sportswriter
Joe Falls, who viewed Colavito as a "self-ordained deity", began going after Colavito in the press and started a feature chronicling the runs he failed to drive in; whenever Colavito stranded a runner, Falls would give him the facetious statistic "RNBI" (Run Not Batted In). This infuriated Colavito and created a tense relationship between the two men for several years. In one game, Falls – acting as the official scorer – charged Colavito with a controversial
error, causing Colavito to confront him after the game. Another time when Colavito was in a batting slump and the Tigers fans started razzing him for it, he threw a ball he barely caught in left field over the right-field light tower and roof. On May 12, 1961, Colavito was ejected from a game with the Yankees in New York after climbing into the stands, which was against MLB rules (though other Tigers players who followed Colavito into the stands were not ejected), to go after a drunken Yankee fan who had been scuffling with his father there after the fan started harassing Colavito's wife. Colavito ($35,000 in 1961) than established team star
Al Kaline ($39,000 to $49,000). In 1962, Colavito had 164 hits (Kaline 121), 37 home runs (Kaline 29), and 112 RBI (Kaline 94). He was selected for both All-Star Games for the third time and homered in Game 2. In 1963, Colavito hit .271, with 22 homers and 91 RBI.
Kansas City Athletics during
spring training in 1964 Colavito was dealt along with
Bob Anderson and $50,000 from the
Tigers to the
Kansas City Athletics for
Jerry Lumpe,
Dave Wickersham and
Ed Rakow on November 18, . but did not win one of the three AL
Gold Glove Awards for an outfielder. On September 6, he got his 1,000th RBI. Not only did he face down Al Kaline and Willie Horton, he further vexed the Tigers by scoring the winning run for the Yanks in the eighth inning. He also homered in the second game. Colavito's pitching feat as a Yankee was not seen again in the AL until May 6,
2012, when
Baltimore Oriole Chris Davis earned a win. Colavito got 20 hits including 5 home runs in 39 games played for the Yankees. He was released by the Yankees on September 30, 1968 He was a first base coach for the Indians during the 1973 season, broadcaster during the 1975 season, and first base coach during the 1977 and 1978 seasons. In 1982, Colavito and
Kansas City Royals Manager
Dick Howser, a former
shortstop for the Indians, were involved in a traffic accident and struggle with police. Colavito and Howser were convicted of interfering with police and received 90-day jail sentences. Both appealed and served six months of probation. Colavito was involved in the 1983
pine tar game and was ejected for arguing the umpires' decision to negate
George Brett's home run and call him out, which would have given the Yankees the win; the decision was later overturned, the game was resumed a month later with the Royals in the lead as the result of Brett's home run, and the Royals won the game. ==Personal life and death==