Allegations of misogyny and racism In August 2009, in his
Spectator blog he wrote about
Harriet Harman, deputy leader of the Labour Party, in unflattering terms. Liddle began the article by asking: "So — Harriet Harman, then. Would you? I mean after a few beers obviously, not while you were sober."
Tanya Gold wrote in
The Guardian that Liddle had delivered a "tissue-thin polemic." Pointing out that it was
The Spectators cover story that week.
Rachel Cooke in
The Observer nearly two months later recalled finding Liddle's piece "disgusting" Cooke went on to say: "I would still like to do something really unpleasant to the man who wrote [the article]." Liddle said two months later that the Harman column "was supposed to be a parody of guttural, base sexism", a joke he assumed readers would understand. After the negative response from Gold (and then Cooke, among other female journalists) he continued: "And then I suppose I came to the conclusion – gradually – that I must have got it wrong." In June 2014, he said that of those he had offended, Harman was the one person to whom he would apologise. In November 2009, again for
The Spectator website, he offered "a quick update on what the Muslim savages are up to," a brief article about the stoning to death of a 20-year-old woman in Somalia after she was accused of adultery, and the similar death of a 13-year-old the year before. He made remarks, considered sarcastic, that read: "Incidentally, many Somalis have come to Britain as immigrants recently, where they are widely admired for their strong work ethic, respect for the law and keen, piercing, intelligence." In December 2009, on his
Spectator blog, Liddle referred to two black music producers, Brandon Jolie and Kingsley Ogundele, who had plotted to kill Jolie's 15-year-old pregnant girlfriend, as "human filth" and said the incident was not an anomaly. He continued: The overwhelming majority of street crime, knife crime, gun crime, robbery and crimes of sexual violence in London is carried out by young men from the
African-Caribbean community. Of course, in return, we have rap music, goat curry and a far more vibrant and diverse understanding of cultures which were once alien to us. For which, many thanks. When he was accused of racism, Liddle said he was instead engaging in a debate about
multiculturalism. In March 2010 the
Press Complaints Commission (PCC) upheld a complaint against Liddle, who became the first journalist to be censured over the contents of a blog, because he had not been able to prove his claim about the crime statistics. After the publication of London crime figures in June 2010,
The Sunday Telegraph suggested Liddle was largely right on some of his claims, but that he was probably wrong on his claims about knife crimes and violent sex crimes. In October 2010, Liddle called for the abolition of the
Welsh language TV channel
S4C as a result of the 2010 Comprehensive Spending Review. In his article for
The Spectator, he described Welsh nationalists as "miserable, seaweed munching, sheep-bothering pinch-faced hill-tribes". On 23 May 2013, Liddle wrote about the murder of soldier
Lee Rigby near the
Royal Artillery Barracks in Woolwich, London. In the original version of a blog article for
The Spectator, he referred to the perpetrators as "two black savages". After many objections to his language use, this phrase was modified. Liddle apologised. Giving a speech at
Durham University in December 2021, Liddle said: "It is fairly easily proven that colonialism is not remotely the major cause of Africa's problems, just as it is very easy to prove that the educational underachievement of British people of Caribbean descent or African Americans is nothing to do with institutional or structural racism."
Independent editor rumour and Millwall supporters' website The Guardian reported on 8 January 2010 that the expected purchase of
The Independent by
Alexander Lebedev, a Russian billionaire, would be followed by the appointment of Liddle as editor.
Roy Greenslade wrote on 11 January that the reports were provoking a "major internal and external revolt" by
The Independent's staff and readers. The stories about Liddle's posts on Millwall Online apparently further reduced the likelihood of his being offered the job.
Tim Luckhurst, professor of journalism at the
University of Kent, argued that Liddle's prospects of editing
The Independent were nullified "by the people behind a viciously intolerant campaign of liberal bigotry". In January 2010, the press drew attention to allegedly racist and misogynist comments posted under the username "monkeymfc"—a name Liddle has used—on Millwall Online, a fan club web forum with no official connection to
Millwall Football Club. Liddle attributed some of the comments to opposition fans logging in under his name to embarrass him. He later said he had written some of the posts that were being criticised, including one in support of the BNP excluding Black and Asian people from the party. Another post, in which he joked about not being able to smoke at
Auschwitz, led to his being asked to explain what he meant in
The Jewish Chronicle. While he said in June 2014 that his comments were taken out of context, he said that he did not regret making them. "No. Never. Absolutely not. I thought about my mates at Millwall Online, God I respect them so much more than these other people, these ghastly fucking people." It was referred to the Attorney General
Dominic Grieve by the judge for possible contempt of court, and he ordered the jurors not to read it. Having decided that it might have breached a court order, Grieve passed the case on to the
Crown Prosecution Service and the Director of Public Prosecutions. The decision that
The Spectator was to be prosecuted by the CPS for breaching reporting restrictions was announced on 9 May 2012, with a court hearing scheduled for 7 June, although Liddle as the author was not himself liable for prosecution.
Fraser Nelson, the magazine's editor, announced that the prosecution would not be contested, and the magazine pleaded guilty at the hearing. The fine was £3,000, plus £2,000 compensation to Stephen Lawrence's parents and £625 costs. In January 2012, Liddle wrote that many people in the UK were "pretending to be disabled" in his column for
The Sun, an opinion defended by
James Delingpole. Frances Ryan in
The Guardian accused him of "belittling something that on a daily basis affects real people" who can be "a huge benefit to society. Maybe for a month Liddle would like to try that." In May 2015, the
Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO) upheld a complaint from
Trans Media Watch that Liddle had been discriminatory towards
Emily Brothers, a blind and
transgender Labour candidate at the
2015 general election, in two
Sun columns published in December 2014 and January 2015. In commenting in the way he had Liddle had breached two sections of the editors' code.
BBC coverage of the death of Nelson Mandela In December 2013 in a blog article for
The Spectator website published shortly after
Nelson Mandela died, Liddle wrote that the BBC coverage on his death was excessive. Richard Garside, director of the
Centre for Crime and Justice Studies, tweeted a "Rod Liddle decision tree" which described Liddle as a "wind-up merchant".
Column on poppers and gay sex During a
parliamentary debate on the Psychoactive Substances Bill – which "makes it an offence to produce, supply, offer to supply, possess with intent to supply, possess on custodial premises, import or export
psychoactive substances" the
Conservative politician
Crispin Blunt admitted he used
poppers: And would be directly affected by this legislation. And I was astonished to find that it's proposed they be banned and, frankly, so were very many gay men. Liddle responded in his
Spectator blog: So, Crispin Blunt MP feels hurt because laws proscribing (or 'poppers') would criminalise the entire gay community. ... I would have thought that the requirement for amyl nitrate to relax the sphincter muscle and lube to accommodate entry was God's way of telling you that what you're about to do is unnatural and perverse. Or your body's way of telling you – your call. So eeeeuw. ... Crispin and others can always use a
jemmy [crowbar] instead. The
satirical and
current affairs magazine Private Eye described this as hypocritical, pointing out Liddle's account in
The Sunday Times of using
Viagra in July 2004. A spokesperson from the
LGBT rights charity
Stonewall said of Liddle's remarks: "Comments like this are shocking and damaging, but we wouldn't expect anything less from repeat offending bigots like Rod Liddle."
Unfair treatment by Newsnight Liddle appeared on the BBC's
Newsnight hosted by
Emily Maitlis to discuss
Brexit on 15 July 2019. In the episode, Maitlis said Liddle wrote columns containing "consistent casual racism week after week" and asked Liddle if he would describe himself as a racist. After the episode was broadcast, a complainant alleged that Maitlis was "sneering and bullying" towards Liddle. An investigation by the BBC upheld these complaints, saying that Maitlis was "persistent and personal" in her criticism of Liddle thus "leaving her open to the charge that she had failed to be even-handed" in the discussion.
Column on Muslim voters In October 2019, Liddle penned a column in
The Spectator commenting on the forthcoming
December 2019 UK general election, which suggested that the election should be held on a Muslim holy day to reduce the Labour vote. The column was criticised by senior political figures including Chancellor of the Exchequer
Sajid Javid and former Conservative
Deputy Prime Minister David Lidington. Liddle defended the content as being humorous. The article also criticised the Labour MP
Rosie Duffield's recent speech about her experience of trying to exit an abusive relationship; Duffield described the article as "racist and misogynistic". ==Books==