Greenbergian tradition Krauss's attempts to understand the phenomenon of modernist art, in its historical, theoretical, and formal dimensions, have led her in various directions. She has, for example, been interested in the development of photography, whose history—running parallel to that of modernist painting and sculpture—makes visible certain previously overlooked phenomena in the "high arts", such as the role of the indexical mark, or the function of the archive. She has also investigated certain concepts, such as "formlessness", "the optical unconscious", or "pastiche", which organize modernist practice in relation to different explanatory grids from those of progressive modernism, or the avant-garde. Like many, Krauss had been drawn to the criticism of
Clement Greenberg, as a counterweight to the highly subjective, poetic approach of
Harold Rosenberg. The poet-critic model proved long-lasting in the New York scene, with products from
Frank O'Hara to Kynaston McShine to
Peter Schjeldahl, but for Krauss and others, its basis in subjective expression was fatally unable to account for how a particular artwork's objective structure gives rise to its associated subjective effects. Greenberg's way of assessing how an art object works, or how it is put together, became for Krauss a fruitful resource; even if she and fellow "Greenberger",
Michael Fried, would break first with the older critic, and then with each other, at particular moments of judgment, the commitment to
formal analysis as the necessary if not sufficient ground of serious criticism would still remain for both of them. Decades after her first engagement with Greenberg, Krauss still used his ideas about an artwork's 'medium' as a jumping-off point for her strongest effort to come to terms with post-1980 art in the person of
William Kentridge. Krauss would formulate this formalist commitment in strong terms, against attempts to account for powerful artworks in terms of residual ideas about an artist's individual genius, for instance in the essays "The Originality of the Avant-Garde: A
Postmodernist Repetition" and "Photography's Discursive Spaces." For Krauss, and for the school of critics who developed under her influence, the Greenbergian legacy offers at its best a way of accounting for works of art using public and hence verifiable criteria.
Translating ephemeralities into prose Whether about (
Cubist collage,
Surrealist photography, early
Giacometti sculpture,
Rodin,
Brâncuși,
Pollock) or about art contemporaneous to her own writing (
Robert Morris,
Sol LeWitt,
Richard Serra,
Cindy Sherman), Krauss translates the ephemeralities of visual and bodily experience into precise, vivid English, which has solidified her prestige as a critic. Her usual practice is to make this experience intelligible by using categories translated from the work of a thinker outside the study of art, such as
Maurice Merleau-Ponty,
Ferdinand de Saussure,
Jacques Lacan,
Jean-François Lyotard,
Jacques Derrida,
Georges Bataille, or
Roland Barthes. Indeed, she participated in the translation of Lacan's key text "
Television" which was published in October and later reissued in book form by
Norton. Her work has helped establish the position of these writers within the study of art, even at the cost of provoking anxiety about threats to the discipline's autonomy. She is currently preparing a second volume of collected essays as a sequel to
The Originality of the Avant Garde and Other Modernist Myths (1986). In many cases, Krauss is credited as a leader in bringing these concepts to bear on the study of modern art. For instance, her
Passages in Modern Sculpture (1977) makes important use of
Merleau-Ponty's phenomenology (as she had come to understand it in thinking about minimal art) for viewing modern sculpture in general. In her study of Surrealist photography, she rejected
William Rubin's efforts at formal categorization as insufficient, instead advocating the psychoanalytic categories of "dream" and "automatism", as well as
Jacques Derrida's "grammatological" idea of "spacing." See "The Photographic Conditions of Surrealism" (
October, winter 1981).
Picasso's collages Concerning Cubist art, she took Picasso's collage breakthrough to be explicable in terms of
Saussure's ideas about the differential relations and non-referentiality of language, rejecting efforts by other scholars to tie the pasted newspaper clippings to social history. Similarly, she held Picasso's stylistic developments in Cubist portraiture to be products of theoretical problems internal to art, rather than outcomes of the artist's love life. Later, she explained Picasso's participation in the ''rappel à l'ordre
or return to order of the 1920s in similar structuralist terms. See "In the Name of Picasso" (October
, spring 1981), "The Motivation of the Sign" (in Lynn Zelevansky, ed., Picasso and Braque: A Symposium
, 1992), and The Picasso Papers'' (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1998).
Freudian theory From the 1980s, she became increasingly concerned with using a
psychoanalytic understanding of drives and the unconscious, owing less to the Freudianism of an
André Breton or a
Salvador Dalí, and much more to the structuralist
Lacan and the "dissident surrealist"
Bataille. See "No More Play", her 1984 essay on
Giacometti, as well as "Corpus Delicti", written for the 1985 exhibition ''L'Amour Fou: Photography and Surrealism
, Cindy Sherman: 1975–1993
and The Optical Unconscious
(both 1993) and Formless: A User's Guide
with Yve-Alain Bois, catalog to the exhibition L'Informe: Mode d'emploi'' (Paris: Centre Pompidou, 1996).
Interpreting Pollock Years after her time at
Artforum in the 1960s, Krauss also returned to the drip painting of
Jackson Pollock as both a culmination of modernist work within the format of the "easel picture", and a breakthrough that opened the way for several important developments in later art, from
Allan Kaprow's happenings to
Richard Serra's lead-flinging process art to
Andy Warhol's oxidation (i.e. urination) paintings. For reference, see the Pollock chapter in
The Optical Unconscious, several entries in the
Formless catalog, and "Beyond the Easel Picture", her contribution to the
MoMA symposium accompanying the 1998 Pollock retrospective (
Jackson Pollock: New Approaches). This direction provided intellectual validation for the explosive Pollock markets; but it exacerbated already tense relations between herself and more radical currents in visual/cultural studies, the latter growing steadily impatient with the traditional western art-historical canon. In addition to writing focused studies about individual artists, Krauss also produced broader, synthetic studies that helped gather together and define the limits of particular fields of practice. Examples of this include "Sense and Sensibility: Reflections on Post '60s Sculpture" (
Artforum, Nov. 1973), "Video: The Aesthetics of Narcissism" (
October, spring 1976), "Notes on the Index: Seventies Art in America", in two parts,
October spring and fall 1977), "Grids, You Say", In
Grids: Format and Image in 20th Century Art (exh. cat.: Pace Gallery, 1978), and "Sculpture in the Expanded Field" (
October, spring 1979). Some of these essays are collected in her book
The Originality of the Avant-Garde and Other Modernist Myths. == Bibliography ==