For Gacioch, the result was a return to baseball as a member of the 1944 Blue Sox. The team was
managed by
Bert Niehoff, the same man that had sent pitcher
Jackie Mitchell to face
Babe Ruth and
Lou Gehrig a decade earlier in an exhibition game. As it is reported, she
struck out Ruth and Gehrig in succession. At the end of the 1945 season, Gacioch was one of the ten players on the Blue Sox that Niehoff asked to have protected from being traded at a league meeting in
Chicago. But the president of the South Bend club decided that Gacioch's poor
English made her a liability for the team, not the
ladylike image he was seeking for his organization. And so he traded her to the
Rockford Peaches for the 1945 season. After the transaction, Gacioch blossomed as one of the most consistent AAGPBL players, starring on four championship teams for the Peaches, and by setting several league records as both a hitter and a pitcher. During her first year in Rockford, she set a league record of 31
assists from the outfield, a mark she matched two years later. Then in the 1946 season, she led the league with nine
triples while hitting a hefty .262 mark for her
batting average. Peaches manager Bill Allington moved Gacioch from the outfield to the
pitcher's mound in 1948, and she responded with a 14–5 mark. Her most productive season came in 1951, when she posted a 20–7 record to become the league's only 20-game winner. She also pitched a
no-hitter in 1953, and while not pitching played in the outfield, she amassed averages of .294 in 1951, .285 in 1953, and a top-career .304 in 1954 at age of 38, when she was old enough to be the mother of some of her teammates. Also in her final season, she recorded a significant total of 13
home runs. A good-contact hitter, Gacioch only struck out 162 times in almost 3,000 career at-bats, and she ranks eighth in the AAGPBL All-Time list with 352
runs batted in. As a pitcher, she won 92 games and lost 60 in 174 appearances. Her skill as an overhand pitcher led to the league's changing its rules in 1947 to allow overhand pitching. She achieved four league championships and made the
All-Star Team in 1951, 1952 and 1953. She retired from baseball after the league disbanded in 1954. ==Personal life==