Pearson was a graduate student at
City College, and the play was read there by
Jill Eikenberry and
Pamela Reed in May 1980. The play was developed by the
Yale Repertory Theatre and first produced in a staged reading at the O'Neill Theater Center,
Waterford, Connecticut in 1980. The play was then produced at the Yale Winterfest in 1981, with Francis Conroy as Sally and
Robin Bartlett as Marsha. Of the 1981 Winterfest production, the
New York Times wrote that this was a play "of promise." "The play occasionally dips into archness and ends on a predictable note, but, as written from a woman's point of view, it has some enlivening and, for men, some disheartening comments on male-female, husband-wife relations...offers two choice, contrasting roles."
Sally and Marsha premiered on February 9, 1982, at the
Off-Broadway Manhattan Theatre Club Stage 73 and ran for 56 performances. It starred
Bernadette Peters as Sally and
Christine Baranski as Marsha. According to
The New York Times, "If the reviews are good, Paramount [Pictures] and Lester Osterman will move the play to Broadway." This production marked the return of Bernadette Peters to the New York stage after eight years, when she joined the production four days before rehearsal. ==Plot==