Ames was appointed by the General Assembly to succeed
William R. Staples as chief justice of the
Rhode Island Supreme Court on June 26, 1856.
Modernizations During his time on the Court, he was a vocal advocate for the jurisprudential benefits of judicial opinions. He required the Court to publish an opinion explaining the facts and its reasoning in all cases; previously, the judges had delivered oral statements or cursory written opinions. He also modernized the Court's rules of procedure and professionalized the Court's reporting. These quality improvements resulted in a significant increase in Rhode Island's judicial caseload; previously, litigants had filed equitable suits in federal court if at all possible, owing in part to equity scholar
Justice Joseph Story's long tenure riding circuit.
Taylor v. Place In his first term on the Court, Ames decided
Taylor v. Place, which abrogated
legislative supremacy over the judiciary. Analyzing the nature of the judicial power, Ames ruled that, under the
1843 Constitution, the General Assembly could no longer pass legislation overruling judgements. Considered the most important opinion in Rhode Island's history,
Taylor drew comparisons to
Chief Justice Marshall's opinion in
Marbury v. Madison and served as an early antecedent to
U.S. v. Klein.
Ames v. Hazard Shortly before joining the bench, Ames represented Ives, the successful plaintiff in
Ives v. Hazard. As Reporter, he prepared the report of the case, leading Hazard to accuse him of libeling him. This led Ames to sue Hazard for libelously accusing him of libel, a dispute that was heard by the Rhode Island Supreme Court in
Ames v. Hazard. == Personal life ==