In 1835, Schieffelin was married to Lucretia Hazard (1816–1899). Together, they were the parents of three children: •
William Henry Schieffelin (1836–1895), who married Mary B. Jay (1846–1916), daughter of
John Jay, the
U.S. Minister to Austria-Hungary, and great-granddaughter
John Jay, the first
Chief Justice of the United States • Alice Holmes Schieffelin (1838–1913), who married Russell Stebbins (1835–1894). • Mary Theresa Bradhurst Schieffelin (1840–1910), who married
Brig. Gen. Charles Cleveland Dodge (1841–1910), who served in the
American Civil War and was the son of Congressman
William Earle Dodge. Schieffelin died at his home, 938
Madison Avenue, on September 13, 1900, in New York.
Descendants Through his son William, he was the grandfather of Eleanor Jay Schiefflin (1864–1929), who married Theodore Munger Taft (1865–1945), and Dr.
William Jay Schieffelin (1866–1955), who married Maria Louise Shepard (1870–1948), the daughter of
Elliot Fitch Shepard and
Margaret Louisa Vanderbilt, and granddaughter of
Cornelius Vanderbilt. who married
Alfred Clark Chapin (1848–1936), former
Mayor of Brooklyn, Samuel Schieffelin Stebbins (1872–1912), a stockbroker, and Russell Hazard Schieffelin (1874–1892). The Chapin's daughter, Samuel's great-granddaughter, Grace Chapin (1885–1960), was married to
Hamilton Fish III (1888–1991), member of the
U.S. House of Representatives. ==Works==