In July 2005, former CBS reporter
Bernard Goldberg ranked Savage as number 61 in his book
100 People Who Are Screwing Up America. Goldberg wrote that "Savage's brand of over-the-top
bile ... puts him right in there with the angriest haters of the
Left."
David Klinghoffer, a
National Review columnist, speculated that
The Savage Nation "is an act, a put-on". On April 17, 2006, Savage said on the topic of Muslims, "They say, 'Oh, there's a billion of them.' I said, 'So, kill 100 million of them, then there'll be 900 million of them.' I mean, would you rather die—would you rather us die than them?" The remarks made by Savage were seriously criticized worldwide and was taken from an argument dealing with the possibility of a nuclear conflict in that region. This was repeated in the media after Savage was barred from entering the UK.
Controversial MSNBC exchange Savage was hired by
MSNBC to do a one-hour show which began in March 2003. Controversy arose four months later over remarks made in response to a caller who insulted Savage's teeth. Savage responded by asking if the caller was a "
sodomite", and when the caller replied that he was, Savage said: "Oh, so you're one of those sodomites. You should only get
AIDS and die, you pig. How's that? Why don't you see if you can sue me, you pig. You got nothing better to do than to put me down, you piece of garbage. You got nothing to do today? Go eat a sausage and choke on it. Get
trichinosis. Now, do we have another nice caller here who's busy because he didn't have a nice night in the bathhouse who's angry at me today? Put another – put another sodomite on ... no more calls? I don't care about these bums, they mean nothing to me. They're all sausages."
Catholic Church and immigration In March 2006, Savage criticized
Roman Catholic assistance to illegal immigrants (in response to statements by Cardinal
Roger Mahony of Los Angeles calling it "pastoral support").
Bill Donohue of the
Catholic League canceled an appearance on the show, saying "what is not fine is Savage's diatribe about the 'greedy pigs' in the Catholic Church and how 'the institution is rotten from the top to the bottom.
C-SPAN broadcast of Talkers Award When
Talkers Magazine awarded Savage with the publication's annual "Freedom of Speech Award",
C-SPAN opted not to broadcast a pre-recorded speech that had been sent by Savage. Although the award ceremony had received coverage in previous years, C-SPAN did not televise it due to its policy of televising such speeches only when delivered in person. Savage told his listeners to express their ire to C-SPAN through calls and e-mails to the organization.
Dispute with CAIR In early November 2007, the
Council on American–Islamic Relations (CAIR) called on radio listeners to contact companies that advertise on Savage's program to express their concerns about his comments concerning Muslims. Savage was quoted as saying Muslims "need
deportation", and that adherents of Islam would do well to "take your religion and shove it up your behind" because "I'm sick of you." On November 5, 2007, following a campaign by CAIR meant to get Savage off the air by alerting his sponsors to the nature of his comments,
Citrix Systems, Inc. pulled its advertisements from his show. Savage sued CAIR for
copyright infringement for using excerpts from his show on CAIR's website. The suit alleged that CAIR's repackaging of Savage's comments was "deliberately designed to obscure the specific message conveyed by Michael Savage". The excerpts included Savage's characterization of the
Qur'an as "a throwback document" and a "book of hate". CAIR called the suit "bizarre, sloppy and baseless". On July 25, 2008,
United States district court Judge
Susan Illston dismissed Savage's suit against CAIR, holding that the posting of the audio clip was protected under
fair use. The court gave Savage the opportunity to file an amended complaint if he wanted to try to cure the defects in his suit. That amended complaint alleged that CAIR was a RICO conspirator in support of terror, including the 9/11 terror attack on the World Trade Center. Permission was granted to allow that filing but on August 14, 2008, however, Savage's lawyer,
Daniel Horowitz, announced that Savage would not file an amended complaint and would drop the case. CAIR then sought attorneys fees against Savage; Judge Illston denied that request.
Autism In July 2008, Savage said that the increasing
rate of
autism diagnoses was the result of "a racket" designed to get disability payments for "poorer families who have found a new way to be parasites on the government." He returned to the subject on his July 16, 2008, show with the following remarks: Also in July 2008, the progressive pressure group
Media Matters for America picketed the studios of
WOR in New York, along with parents of autistic children. WOR issued a statement saying, "We regret any consternation that his remarks may have caused to our listeners." and the
Supertalk Mississippi radio network dropped Savage's program, replacing it with
The Dennis Miller Show. Later that evening, Savage devoted his entire three-hour program to the subject, taking calls from parents who took issue with his comments. On that show Savage stated that his remarks had been "ripped out of context" by "far left
Stalinists" who want him off of the air. He appeared on
Larry King Live with
Glenn Beck as the substitute host for
Larry King, and said that the real issue he was commenting on was the
overdiagnosis of children due to
pharmaceutical companies' drive to drug children for higher profits. Savage's syndicator,
Talk Radio Network, responded by releasing a lengthy statement, along with a selection of 20 audio clips drawn from Savage's discussions of autism, to show that the comments were taken out of context.
United Kingdom entry ban On May 5, 2009, it was announced by then-
Home Secretary Jacqui Smith of the
Labour party that Savage was on a
list of people banned from entering the United Kingdom as he is "considered to be engaging in unacceptable behavior by seeking to provoke others to serious criminal acts and fostering
hatred which might lead to inter-community violence". During his radio broadcast on that same day, Savage threatened to sue Smith for
defamation. During a subsequent
NPR talk show, Savage said that he has never advocated violence and repeatedly invoked the
United States Constitution's
First Amendment. After host
Neal Conan pointed out that the U.S. Constitution does not apply to the United Kingdom, Savage replied, "No. Thank God I'm an American. But for this lunatic ... to link me up with
Nazi skinheads who are killing people in
Russia ... to put me in league with
Hamas murderers who killed Jews on buses, is astonishing." Savage also called on his listeners to support him by canceling travel and business in Britain as well as by boycotting British-made goods, commenting, "If they want to play hardball, we'll play hardball." When a caller challenged Savage about his talk show rhetoric, Savage called him a "foaming lunatic ... someone in pajamas in a mental asylum ... You're nobody and I'm not going to talk to you!" At that point, Neal Conan invited him to leave. After Johnson became
Prime Minister in 2019, Savage's attorney requested the ban be overturned, however no action was taken by the
Conservative government. In
The Guardian,
Catherine Bennett wrote: "The ban on Savage is so far from being a comprehensible act, so staggeringly capricious and stupid, as to defy evaluation."
Sam Leith wrote: "Barring this shock-jock from Britain risks turning a rabid blabbermouth into a beacon for free speech." ==Personal life==