Colonial era Caleb Heathcote purchased land that would become Scarsdale at the end of the 17th century and, on March 21, 1701, had it elevated to a royal manor. He named the lands after his
ancestral home in
Derbyshire, England. The first local census of 1712 counted twelve inhabitants, including seven African
slaves. When Caleb died in 1721, his daughters inherited the property. The estate was broken up in 1774, and the town was officially founded on March 7, 1788.
1790–1945 According to the first federal census in 1790, the town's population was 281. According to the 1840 census, that number had declined to 255 but recent research has indicated that this was a clerical error. The true population climbed slowly from 317 in 1830 to 342 in 1850 — the vast majority farmers and farm workers. In 1846, the
New York and Harlem Railroad connected Scarsdale to New York City, leading to an influx of commuters. The Arthur Suburban Home Company purchased a farm in 1891 and converted it into a subdevelopment of one-family dwellings, starting a transformation of the community from rural to suburban. Civil institutions soon appeared: the Heathcote Association (1904), the Town Club (1904), the Scarsdale Woman's Club (1918) and the Scarsdale League of Women Voters (1921).
Scarsdale High School and Greenacres Elementary School were built in 1912, and the Edgewood Elementary School opened in 1918. The first store in Scarsdale opened on the corner of Popham Road and Garth Road in 1912. By 1915, the population approached 3000. By 1930, that number approached 10,000. In 1940,
Nazi agent
Gerhardt Alois Westrick secretly met with American business leaders at his Scarsdale home until public pressure—a reaction to articles in the
New York Herald Tribune produced by
British Security Coordination in New York—drove his family from the community. He was subsequently deported for pursuing activities unfriendly to the United States.
1945–present Scarsdale became the subject of national controversy in the 1950s when a "Committee of Ten" led by
Otto Dohrenwend alleged "
Communist infiltration" in the public schools. A thorough investigation by the town rejected these claims. This same group, known as the Scarsdale Citizens Committee, sued to prevent a benefit for the
Freedom Riders from taking place at the public high school in 1963 because some of the performers (
Ossie Davis,
Ruby Dee,
Pete Seeger) were allegedly "communist sympathizers and subversives." Another controversy enveloped the town in 1961, when the Scarsdale Golf Club, headed by Charles S. McCallister, refused to allow a young man who had converted from
Judaism into the
Episcopal Church, Michael Cunningham Hernstadt, to escort a young woman, Pamela Nottage, to her debut at the club. At the time, it was the club's policy to prohibit Jews from the premises. In response, the Rev. George French Kempsell of the Church of Saint James the Less announced that he would ban any supporters of the club's decision from receiving Holy Communion. The driving force behind the library was New York City publisher
S. Spencer Scott, who raised $100,000 for the project after the village rejected a bond issue to fund the building in 1938. The new library opened with 27,000 books and Sylvia C. Hilton serving as the first librarian. In 1967,
U.S. Secretary of State and former longtime resident
Dean Rusk returned to Scarsdale at the height of the
Vietnam War to receive the town's Man of the Year Award and was greeted with a silent protest. Scarsdale was the subject of a landmark
United States Supreme Court decision,
ACLU v. Scarsdale (1985), that established the so-called "reindeer rule" regarding public
nativity scenes and upheld the right of local religious groups to place crèches on public property. Scarsdale was involved in another
United States Supreme Court case in 1985,
Board of Trustees of Scarsdale v. McCreary, concerning the display of privately sponsored nativity scenes on public property. On January 1, 2022, the village of Scarsdale banned the sale of all tobacco and cannabis products as well as smoking on public property for people of all ages. After the 60 day grace period, a 100 dollar fine will be imposed by law enforcement on violators. ==Geography==