Comments, arguments and opinions In August 2017, Lucas was criticised for suggesting that the arguments used to justify same-sex marriage could equally be used to justify incest. On 29 August 2022, the SFP tweeted a picture of
Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon outside
Auschwitz, with a cartoon thought bubble reading: "There should have been a
buffer zone around this place".
Green MSP
Gillian Mackay, responsible for the Act that created buffer zones around
abortion clinics targeted by anti-abortion protesters, described the meme as "crass, insensitive and shameful" and that "even by [the SFP's] standards, this is appalling". SFP was referenced in the 2022
Hope not Hate 'State of Hate Report' claiming that the party spread an increasing amount of anti-trans and anti-LGBT+ campaign material and content on its social media, arguing that "
transgender ideology is damaging and confusing children". The party would seek to repeal the new smacking ban legislation, since it believes that the previous legislation was adequate to protect children; and it opposes the
UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, saying that it undermines the rights of parents. The SFP also opposes hate crime legislation. It has been alleged that Lucas spreads misinformation about the sexual health curriculum in schools. One teacher spoke to
The National newspaper, linking SFP rhetoric to abuse of LGBT+ teachers and to incidents of teachers being called perverts or groomers in the street, abused as "paedophiles" over the phone, or in the case of some LGBT+ teachers, "forced out of the profession altogether".
Alleged breach of electoral law According to
The Ferret, Lucas was revealed on 27 July 2020 to have breached electoral law by failing to submit a record before the deadline of his personal campaign spending after running in the 2019 general election – he had provided information to the Electoral Commission but not the local returning officer for the constituency he contested.
Alleged links to far-right organisations In January 2023,
The Ferret reported that SFP leader Richard Lucas was interviewed by Simon Crane, a prominent member of the
far-right hate group Patriotic Alternative (PA) in Scotland. PA had been targeted by the UK government counter-terrorism strategy. Crane also interviewed SFP member and activist Niall Fraser. Lucas said Crane used to be a member of the Scottish Family Party (SFP), but left "after discussions with myself led him to the conclusion that PA reflected his ethno-nationalist political stance while the SFP did not". Lucas added that he takes "any opportunity to present the SFP to a new audience" and would "probably" speak to PA again. In March 2023,
PinkNews described the group as "far-right" due to plans to "brick up" the Sandyford Clinic in Glasgow in a protest against gender affirming care. Fraser announced in late August 2023 that he would be contesting
Margaret Ferrier's MP seat in
Rutherglen and Hamilton West. According to the
Daily Record, "Fraser appeared on a podcast by neo-Nazi group
Homeland on which he described
COVID-19 as "bogus" and said: "I didn't follow any
lockdowns." Georgie Laming, campaign director of the advocacy group
Hope not Hate, said: "Niall Fraser and the Scottish Family Party say they're standing up for traditional family values, however the truth is very sinister. We've found they're cosying up to
fascist group Homeland". == Electoral history ==