The Screaming Skull was released in August 1958, on a double bill with
Terror from the Year 5000. It was never registered with a copyright office, despite the presence of an onscreen copyright notice belonging to Madera Productions. Erick Harper of
DVD Verdict remarked that the film was "of questionable value" and opined it was a "truly awful example of drive-in cinema." He believed that the film was not "worth the time to watch."
Leonard Maltin gave the film one and a half stars, calling it "dreary," but he believed that it became "reasonably eerie toward the end, with a twist that's actually a surprise." Authors
Phil Hardy and
Tom Milne wrote of the film: "Nicol, an actor here directing for the first time, lets the action spin out much too slackly, dissipating the grasp of moody tension he displayed in his unpretentiously excellent war movie,
Three Came Back." Film historian
Steven H. Scheuer graded the film one and a half stars, writing "Wife is terrorized by unexplainable happenings. Or is it inexplicable? Both describe the film." ''VideoHound's Golden Movie Retriever'' by Jim Craddock also gave the film one and a half stars, and
TV Guide gave it two. Webber herself did not like the film, stating that "it didn't impress me" and she "wanted to throw up" after watching it. However, Nicol took a more positive stance, saying "I liked it. It had some nice dolly shots, a good atmosphere. So I was happy with that. It was a nice change from the films I'd been doing."
Mystery Science Theater 3000 The Screaming Skull was featured in episode 912 of
Mystery Science Theater 3000, a comedy television series which features a human and two robots watching bad films while providing a running commentary which mocks the film being shown. The
MST3K episode premiered August 29, 1998, and included an episode of
The Gumby Show titled "Robot Rumpus." Series writer
Bill Corbett disliked the film, saying that "making someone watch this even once is specifically outlawed by the Geneva Convention." The episode featuring the film was the final episode broadcast on
The Sci-Fi Channel, when it aired as a rerun on January 31, 2004. In
Paste, writer Jim Vorel ranked the episode #112 in his evaluation of
MST3K's first twelve seasons. Vorel offers more praise than usual in his evaluation of the movie, writing it "has a serious, almost Universal horror-like tone, and honestly is more or less competent despite offering the gimmick of 'free burial services' to anyone who dies of fright while watching." He also calls
The Screaming Skull "a very low-key film, sort of a low-rent version of
The Innocents". In
Vulture, writer Courtney Enlow listed
The Screaming Skull among the 25 most essential episodes of
Mystery Science Theater. The
MST3K version of the film was included as part of the
Mystery Science Theater 3000, Volume XXXI: The Turkey Day Collection DVD set, released by
Shout! Factory on November 25, 2014. Special features included with the episode include the movie's theatrical trailer and two featurettes: "Gumby & Clokey: The Making of Robot Rumpus" and "This Film May Kill You!: Making
The Screaming Skull". The other episodes in the four-disc set include
Jungle Goddess (#203),
The Painted Hills (#510), and
Squirm (#1012). ==See also==