Although Microsoft had attacked Google in its advertising before, the Scroogled campaign began in November 2012, attacking the
Google Shopping service for its shift to a
pay-per-click (PPC) model in which retailers are required to pay Google to have products listed, and are ranked in search results by their payments and relevance. The site suggested that users use Microsoft's competing
Bing Shopping service instead, which had previously vowed not to shift to a PPC model. The next campaign in February 2013 incorporated elements of
advocacy, attacking
Gmail for using the contents of messages to generate
targeted advertising, and recommending
Outlook.com instead. The site also featured a survey of 1,000 users against the service's advertising practices, and a
petition calling upon Google to stop engaging in the practice. In April 2013, Microsoft attacked
Android, citing a recent allegation that
Google Play Store had been, without disclosure, leaking basic personal information about users (including names, email addresses, and phone numbers) to application developers. In August 2013, alongside the launch of its Bing for Schools initiative, Microsoft argued that Google's use of advertising on search results pages in an educational environment could "distract [students] from their studies", unlike the ad-free version of Bing that can be enabled through the Bing for Schools program. In November 2013, Microsoft began to offer Scroogled merchandise through
Microsoft Store, such as shirts and mugs featuring designs attacking Google's privacy practices. That same month, Microsoft also released a Scroogled ad starring
Rick Harrison in parody of his television series
Pawn Stars, which saw Harrison rejecting a
Chromebook at his
pawn shop due to its reliance on web-based software, as opposed to a "traditional" computer with
Windows and
Microsoft Office. == Legacy ==