used in the film docked in San Diego, 2012|alt=HMS
Surprise (replica) Weir, asked in 2005 if he would make a
sequel, stated he thought it "most unlikely", and after internet rumors to the contrary, stated "I think that while it did well...
ish at the box office, it didn't generate that monstrous, rapid income that provokes a sequel." In 2007 the film was included on a list of "13 Failed Attempts To Start Film Franchises" by
The A.V. Club, noting that "this surely stands as one of the most exciting opening salvos in nonexistent-series history, and the Aubrey–Maturin novels remain untapped cinematic ground."
Naomi Novik, a
fantasy author, credits the inspiration for her
alternative history series
Temeraire where
dragons fight in the Napoleonic Wars, as coming from a "naval adventure Napoleonic phase" instigated by watching
Master and Commander then reading the Aubrey-Maturin books. Starting by writing
fan fiction based on the Aubrey-Maturin characters, Novik eventually would develop her idea of introducing dragons to the Napoleonic wars in what would become the first book in her series, 2006's ''His Majesty's Dragon.'' In 2009 Crowe claimed in an interview with the Associated Press he was in negotiations for a sequel to the film based on the eleventh book from the Aubrey-Maturin series
The Reverse of the Medal. In December 2010, Crowe launched an appeal on
Twitter to get the sequel made: "If you want a
Master and Commander sequel I suggest you e-mail
Tom Rothman at Fox and let him know your thoughts". Film critic Scott Tobias wrote a positive retrospective article about this film in 2019, begrudging the fact that
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl, another sea-faring film also released in 2003, had led to a string of
Pirates of the Caribbean fantasy films, but there was no demand for a sequel featuring Captain Jack Aubrey and deeply rooted in historical facts of the Napoleonic Wars, the
Age of Sail and the
Age of Discovery. In summer 2020,
Vulture noted that the "film is ripe for reappraisal." In January 2021, Crowe publicly defended the film from criticism. A March 2023 story in
GQ noted the film's continued popularity among millennial men who were watching the film on streaming services. It theorized that this was in part due to the film's portrayal of "non-toxic masculinity" and strong male friendships, particularly the one between Aubrey and Maturin. "Overall, the masculinity of
Master and Commander ... is overwhelmingly wholesome and positive," reporter Gabriella Paiella wrote. "Any nostalgia for the traditionalism in the movie is less reactionary and more about the healthy male bonding between the characters." That was contrasted with continued problems with
male bonding among 2020s American men. In a 2020 retrospective interview discussing both the Aubrey-Maturin books and the film, author Rachel McMillan discussed her opinion on the film as a longtime fan of the original books stating it "captured the essence of the 21 stories as well as the central relationship between Jack and Stephen" and praises Peter Weir's directing. McMillan notes though she finds the film to be "deprived of the women who make the series so exceptional" noting the absence of book characters such as
Diana Villiers and Sophie Aubrey as significant omissions in the film along with the lack of Stephen's espionage career. Hunt also expressed his desire to see more of the series adapted to film, particular noting his desire to have seen the espionage plots in ''
Treason's Harbour'' explored in film. A tall ship appearing in the background of
Deadpool & Wolverine in 2024 was speculated to be a reference to
Master and Commander, and the claim was initially backed by the film's director
Shawn Levy in a press interview. Levy would retract his statement after consulting with the film's visual effects artists and confirming the 3D model was a generic tall ship. In 2025, it was one of the films voted for the "Readers' Choice" edition of
The New York Times list of "The 100 Best Movies of the 21st Century," finishing at number 190.
Prequel In June 2021, it was reported that a second film is in development by
20th Century Studios, a
prequel based on the first novel only, with
Patrick Ness penning the script. As of October 2024, the studio was looking for a director. == Notes ==