Theatrical success When Finch arrived in Britain, success came relatively early. Harry Watt arranged for a screen test at Ealing Studios, which led to Finch being cast as a murderous actor in the movie
Train of Events (1949) under the direction of
Basil Dearden. While making the film, Olivier cast Finch as a Pole in a stage play at
The Old Vic,
James Bridie's
Daphne Laureola (1949) supporting
Edith Evans. This was a significant critical and commercial success and established Finch in London immediately. Olivier signed Finch to a five-year contract. When
Train of Events was released, critic
C. A. Lejeune praised Finch's work in the London
Observer, commenting that he "adds good cheekbones to a quick intelligence and is likely to become a cult, I fear."
The Scotsman said Finch "should be regarded as one of the most hopeful recruits to the British screen." Finch had a small role as an Australian
prisoner of war in the World War two drama
The Wooden Horse (1950), directed by Jack Lee; this film would be the third-most-popular film at the British box office in 1950. Finch's performance as a Pole in
Daphne Laureola led to his casting as a Polish soldier in
The Miniver Story (1950), the British-filmed sequel to the wartime morale boosting film
Mrs. Miniver; unlike its predecessor, it was poorly received critically, but it did give Finch an experience of working for a movie financed by a major Hollywood studio. During this time, Finch continued to appear on stage in various productions while under contract to Olivier. He directed a stage production of
The White Falcon in January 1950. In February 1950 he toured in a production of
The Damascus Blade by
Bridget Boland under the direction of Olivier, co starring with John Mills. Finch returned to the London stage in
Captain Carvallo by
Denis Cannan, once more directed by Olivier. Finch's closeness to the Olivier family led to an affair with Olivier's wife,
Vivien Leigh, which began in 1948, and continued on and off for several years, ultimately ending because of Leigh's deteriorating mental condition. In March 1951 Finch replaced
Dirk Bogarde for six weeks in a production of
Point of Departure by
Jean Anouilh. Later that year he played Iago opposite
Orson Welles in a production of
Othello, directed by Welles. Despite his stage experience, according to the Sunday Times Finch, like his mentor Olivier, had
stage fright, He also did
Romeo and Juliet at the Old Vic, playing Mercutio, to strong reviews. He then made two films for
Alexander Korda. In
The Story of Gilbert and Sullivan (1953) Finch played
Richard D'Oyly Carte opposite Robert Morley and Maurice Evans in the lead; the resulting movie was a box office disappointment. In
The Heart of the Matter (1953), from the
Graham Greene novel, Finch played a priest opposite Trevor Howard; his performance was a critical success. Finch returned to the stage at the Old Vic with an appearance in
An Italian Straw Hat by
Eugène Labiche and Marc Michel adapted by Thomas Walton. He then received an offer from Paramount to star in
Elephant Walk (1954), shot in Ceylon and Los Angeles. The part was intended for
Laurence Olivier who turned it down, but
Vivien Leigh agreed to play the female lead; Dana Andrews was the other star. The circumstances of production were turbulent; Leigh had a nervous breakdown during production, leading to her being replaced by
Elizabeth Taylor. The experience helped sour Finch on a Hollywood career and he would only work occasionally there for the rest of his career. Back in England, Finch was cast as the villain
Flambeau in
Father Brown (1954), receiving superb reviews opposite
Alec Guinness in the title role. He narrated a documentary
The Queen in Australia and had his first real star part in the Group 3/British Lion comedy,
Make Me an Offer (1954), playing an antiques dealer. He was then a villain in the medieval swashbuckler
The Dark Avenger (1955), opposite another Australian,
Errol Flynn, for Allied Artists. He was much in demand. C.G. Scrimgeour of Associated TV wanted Finch to play a patrol officer in a film based on Colin Simpson's articles about Shangri-La Valley in New Guinea. The Rank organisation wanted him to star in a film directed by Hugh Stewart called
The Flying Doctor.
Under contract to Rank and stardom during filming of
Passage Home (1955) In November 1954 Finch's contract with Olivier (five years extended to six) had expired and he signed a seven-year contract with the
Rank Organisation worth £87,500 to make one film a year for them. "We are going to build Peter into a major British star", said
Earl St. John, Rank's head of production, at the time. Finch's first roles for Rank under the new arrangement gave him star parts but were, on the whole, undistinguished:
Passage Home (1955), a drama with Anthony Steel and fellow Australian
Diane Cilento;
Josephine and Men (1955), a comedy from the Boulting Brothers with
Glynis Johns and
Donald Sinden; and
Simon and Laura (1955), a comedy with
Kay Kendall based on a hit play. None of these films performed particularly well at the box office. Finch was then cast as an Australian soldier in
A Town Like Alice (1956), opposite
Virginia McKenna under the direction of Jack Lee from the novel by
Neville Shute. The World War II drama, mostly set in Malaya and almost entirely shot at Pinewood Studios, became the third-most-popular film at the British box office in 1956 and won Finch a BAFTA for Best Actor. Finch followed it with another war movie,
The Battle of the River Plate (1956), playing Captain
Hans Langsdorff for the team of Powell and Pressburger. This was also hugely popular at home, and British exhibitors voted Finch the seventh-most-popular British star at the box office for 1956. In October 1956, John Davis, managing director of Rank, announced him as one of the actors under contract that Davis thought would become an international star. Finch returned to Australia to make
The Shiralee (1957), made for Ealing Studios and MGM from the novel by
D'Arcy Niland, under the direction of Leslie Norman. It was one of Finch's favourite parts; the resulting movie was critically acclaimed and the tenth-most-popular movie at the British box office that year. Finch followed it with another Australian story filmed on location, the
bushranger tale
Robbery Under Arms (1957), which did less well, despite having the same producer and director as
A Town Like Alice.
Filmink argued Finch's "character could be removed from the final movie, and it wouldn't have affected anything... a character with no romance, no moral core, no purpose in the story, no point." However, exhibitors still voted Finch the third-most-popular British star of 1957, and the fifth most popular overall, regardless of nationality. Finch's next two films for Rank were not particularly successful: ''
Windom's Way (1957), where he played a doctor caught up in the Malayan Emergency (the film was shot in Corsica and London); and Operation Amsterdam (1959), a war-time diamond thriller. Finch returned to the stage for the London production of Two for the Seesaw'' by
William Gibson, under the direction of
Arthur Penn. ==''The Nun's Story'' and international stardom==