Manhattan SC While at college, Mohammed also played for
Manhattan SC during the
2022 USL League Two season. On 15 June, Mohammed made his club debut against the
Long Island Rough Riders, assisting in the lone winning goal and marking his only goal contribution for the team. In total, Mohammed made five appearances, including one in the playoffs, as the team topped the
Metropolitan Division.
Orlando City In December 2022, Mohammed declared early for the
2023 MLS SuperDraft, signing a
Generation Adidas contract with
Major League Soccer to forgo the remainder of his college eligibility. He was drafted in the first round (2nd overall) by
Orlando City after the club traded away
Ruan to
D.C. United earlier in the day to acquire the pick. On 26 March 2023, Mohammed made his professional debut with the reserve team,
Orlando City B, when he came on for Cristofer Acuña in the 67th-minute of a 3–1 win at
Philadelphia Union II. On 29 May, Mohammed scored his first goal for the reserve side when he netted the deciding goal of a 3–2 win over
New York Red Bulls II. In Mohammed's debut season with the reserve team, he scored six goals and made four assists across 25 appearances, making him the second highest goalscorer and goal contributor for the team behind
Jack Lynn. On 27 February 2024, Mohammed made his debut for the club in round one of the
2024 CONCACAF Champions Cup when he started in a 3–1 win over
Cavalry FC before he came off in the 46-minute for
César Araújo. On 18 March, Mohammed made his league debut for the senior team when he came on as an 87th-minute substitute for
Nicolás Lodeiro in a 2–0 loss to
Atlanta United. In the
2024 season, Mohammed tallied 11 goals and two assists across 27 appearances, making him the top goalscorer for the reserve side and third highest goal contributor behind
Alex Freeman and
Yutaro Tsukada. In the
2025 season for the reserve team, Mohammed finished as the top goalscorer for the team for a second consecutive season with 11 goals, but made zero assists, across 27 appearances. Mohammed placed second behind Justin Ellis for the most goal contributions across the season for the team. After the conclusion of the season, Orlando City opted not to extend his contract.
Nashville SC On 7 January 2026, Orlando City announced that they had acquired
Nashville SC's natural third round pick in the
2027 MLS SuperDraft in exchange for Orlando's
right of first refusal on Mohammed. Later the same day, Nashville SC signed Mohammed through the
2026 season with a team option for the
2027 and
2027–28 seasons. Mohammed made his Nashville SC debut as a substitute in their
CONCACAF Champions Cup second leg tie against
Atlético Ottawa on 24 February. Mohammed provided his first goal contribution for the club, an assist to
Ahmed Qasem, to win the game 5–0 and 7–0 on aggregate. On 2 March, Mohammed made his debut for and scored two goals for Nashville SC's MLS Next Pro affiliate,
Huntsville City FC, in a 3–1 win over his former club Orlando City B. Mohammed made his league debut for Nashville SC on 18 April, and scored his first Major League Soccer goal in a 2–0 win at Atlanta United. ==Career statistics==