Background Rugby has provided one of the most visible and lasting examples of the tension between amateurism and professionalism during the development of nationally organised sports in
Britain in the late-19th century. The split in rugby in 1895 between what became
rugby league and
rugby union arose as a direct result of a dispute over the pretence of a strict enforcement of its amateur status – clubs in
Leeds and
Bradford were fined after compensating players for missing work, whilst at the same time the
Rugby Football Union (RFU) was allowing other players to be paid. Rugby football, despite its origins in the privileged English
public schools, was a popular game throughout
England by around 1880, including in the large working-class areas of the industrial north. However, as the then-amateur sport became increasingly popular and competitive, attracting large paying crowds, teams in such areas found it difficult to attract and retain good players. This was because physically fit local men needed to both work to earn a wage – limiting the time that they could devote to unpaid sport – and to avoid injuries that might prevent them working in the future. Certain teams faced with these circumstances wanted to pay so-called 'broken time' money to their players to compensate them for missing paid work due to their playing commitments, but this contravened the amateur policy of the
Rugby Football Union (RFU).
Organization Following a lengthy dispute on this point during the early 1890s, representatives of more than 20 prominent northern rugby clubs met in
Huddersfield in August 1895 to form the
Northern Rugby Football Union (NRFU), a breakaway administrative body which would permit payments to be made to players. The NRFU initially adopted established RFU rules for the game itself, but soon introduced a number of changes, most obviously a switch from 15 to 13 players per side. It became the
Rugby Football League in 1922, by which time the key differences in the two codes were well established, with the 13-a-side variant becoming known as rugby league. The RFU took strong action against the clubs involved in the formation of the NRFU, all of whom were deemed to have forfeited their amateur status and therefore to have left the RFU. A similar interpretation was applied to all players who played either for or against such clubs, whether or not they themselves received any compensation. Such players were effectively barred
sine die from any involvement in organised rugby union. These comprehensive and enduring sanctions, combined with the very localised nature of most rugby competition, meant that most northern clubs had little practical alternative but to affiliate with the NRFU in the first few years of its existence. Rugby football in Britain therefore became subject to a de facto schism along regional – and to some extent class – lines, reflecting the historical origins of the split. Rugby league – in which professionalism was permitted – was predominant in northern England, particularly in industrial areas, and was viewed as a working class game. Rugby union – which remained amateur – was predominant in the rest of England, as well as in
Wales and
Scotland. Rugby union also had a more affluent reputation, although there are areas – notably in
South Wales and in certain English cities such as
Gloucester – with a strong working-class rugby union tradition.
Discrimination Discrimination against rugby league players could verge on the petty – former Welsh international
Fred Perrett was once excluded in lists of players who died in the First World War due to his 'defection' to the league code. One
Member of Parliament,
David Hinchliffe, described it as "one of the longest (and daftest) grievances in history" with anyone over the age of 18 associated with rugby league being banned forever from rugby union.
Scotland and Wales The
Scottish Rugby Union was a particular bastion of amateurism and extreme care was taken to avoid the 'taint' of professionalism: a player rejoining the national team after the end of the Second World War applied to be issued with a new shirt and was reminded that he had been
supplied with a shirt prior to the outbreak of hostilities. In Wales the position was more equivocal with clubs attempting to stem the tide of players
going north with
boot money, a reference to the practice of putting cash payments into player's footwear whilst they were cleaning up after a game. Sometimes payments were substantial.
Barry John was once asked why he hadn't turned professional and responded, "I couldn't afford to."
Open union Rugby union was declared "open" in August 1995 – almost exactly 100 years after the original split occurred – meaning that professionalism has been permitted in both rugby codes since that date. However, while the professional-amateur divide remained in force, there was originally very limited crossover between the two codes, the most obvious occasions being when top-class rugby union players 'switched codes' to rugby league in order to play professionally. Welsh international
Jonathan Davies was a high-profile example of this switch. Since professionalism has been allowed in rugby union the switches have started to come the opposite way. Union has swiftly grown to embrace the professional game with many league players joining union to take a slice of the larger amounts of money available in the sport. Nowadays, while rugby union no longer makes the professional-amateur distinction, the professional-amateur split still exists within rugby league with the
British Amateur Rugby League Association (BARLA) strictly amateur, though it allows some ex-professionals to play provided they are no longer under contract. The most recent club to get a ban for fielding a contracted professional was Brighouse Rangers who were expelled from the
National Conference League during 2007–2008 season, and the player handed a sine die ban (though in part for gouging ), although the club itself has since been admitted to the Pennine League. Also, some rugby unions have amateur rules, most notably the
Argentine Rugby Union, where all member clubs are amateur. The
Campeonato Argentino, the national championship for provincial teams, does not include players contracted to the country's
Super Rugby side, the
Jaguares. ==Ultimate and disc sports (Frisbee)==