Gugerty made his MMA debut in 2005, defeating
Cub Swanson at Total Combat 4. He went on to appear prominently in Total Combat, then moved upwards to the UFC when he was to appear against the then-undefeated
Dale Hartt at
UFC Fight Night: Silva vs. Irvin. Gugerty defeated Hartt by submission in the first round. Gugerty went on to appear against
Spencer Fisher at
UFC 90, as a last-minute replacement for
Melvin Guillard. Fisher submitted Gugerty in the third round via triangle choke. Gugerty would later defeat wrestling specialist
Matt Grice at
UFC 100 with a guillotine choke in the first round. Gugerty fought
Terry Etim on November 14, 2009, at
UFC 105. He lost via submission (guillotine choke) in the second round. Etim had the guillotine locked in for almost 30 seconds before Gugerty tapped. Gugerty faced
Clay Guida on March 21, 2010, at
UFC LIVE: Vera vs. Jones, replacing an injured
Sean Sherk. Gugerty lost via second round submission. Following his loss to Guida, Gugerty was released from the promotion. ==Mixed martial arts record==