The novel's opening sentence was singled out and praised by many critics for its strength and for being memorable. Saudamini Jain of
Hindustan Times praised Doshi's characterization in the novel, writing, "Their feelings and resentments — even in alien situations — are uncannily identifiable." Esha Datanwala of
Scroll.in gave the novel a rave review, praising its narrative structure and Doshi for knowing "exactly how to make her characters human, how to describe Pune and Bombay to elicit nostalgia, how to cut through the frivolity of modern writers and say exactly what is appropriate." Rohan Manoj of
The Hindu agreed, praising Doshi's "crisp prose" and her "powers of observation" regarding human relationships and the "physical reality" of both Pune and Mumbai. Paromita Chakrabarti of
The Indian Express called it a "hard, unflinching look at familial bonds and how they damn us and unravel us."
Urvashi Bahuguna of
India Today praised the novel for revealing "the limited power afforded to women and the price they pay for acting in their own interest." Francesca Carington of
The Daily Telegraph gave the novel a perfect 5 out of 5 stars rating, praising Doshi's "feverish prose" and calling it a "corrosive, compulsive debut." In his review for
The Times, John Self called it "a good debut, but by declaring it one of the year's very best novels, the Booker judges might have given it as much a burden as an accolade." Alex Peake-Tomkinson of
The Times Literary Supplement praised the rapid changes in tone of Doshi's prose for enlivening the novel but largely criticized it for capitulating to an "urge to shock", calling the novel "needlessly depressing" at times. Elle Hunt of
The Guardian called it "an unsettling, sinewy debut, startling in its venom and disarming in its humour from the very first sentence". Judges of the prize called the novel an "utterly compelling read" that "examines a complex and unusual mother-daughter relationship with honest, unflinching realism – sometimes emotionally wrenching but also cathartic, written with poignancy and memorability." It was longlisted for the 2019 Tata Literature Live! First Book Award for Fiction. == Adaptations ==