Toronto Blue Jays (1993–1999) Green made his Major League debut on September 28 as the second-youngest player in the Major Leagues. He hit .329 in late innings of close games. He also made a second notable decision on September 26, donating his day's pay of $75,000 ($ in 2025) to a charity for survivors of the New York
9/11 terrorist attacks. Green started off slowly in , but turned things around with a record-setting power display. On May 23, the turning point of his season, he had one of the best single game performances ever. He hit a Major League record-tying four home runs and a record-tying five extra-base hits (he hit a double in addition to the home runs) against the Milwaukee Brewers, and had 19 total bases, breaking
Joe Adcock's 1954 Major League record by one, while matching the major league record of six runs scored in one game. This record has since been matched by
Nick Kurtz in 2025. No other major league player had six hits, five runs, and as many as four extra-base hits in a game again until
Ian Kinsler of the
Texas Rangers in 2009. He hit a fifth home run during the following game to tie the Major League two-game home run record (five), and then hit two more the game after to break the Major League three-game record (seven). Green also broke the NL record with nine home runs in that calendar week. He was voted to the All-Star team, and finished the season with a .285 average, .385
On-base percentage (a career best), 42 home runs (third in the league), 114 RBIs (fourth in the league), 114 runs (fourth in the league), 93 walks (a career best), 22 intentional walks (fifth in the league), and 20 stolen bases. His home run against the Mets on April 11 was the ninth-longest in the NL for the year, and only two longer home runs were hit in the AL. He also had another bright point—he struck out only 15.5% of the time, his best career year through 2006. He faded as the season progressed, dropping 65 points—and batting .240—after the All Star break. After the season ended, Green was 18th of all active players in doubles (and younger than all those ahead of him), and in the top thirty of all active players in home runs, runs, total bases, and extra base hits. He was also in the top 100 of all players ever lifetime in home runs. 2006 marked only the second post-season appearance of Green's career. In the 2006 playoffs, Green tied for the team lead with three doubles, and hit .313, second best on the team (as the Mets hit only .250). The report came amid retirement rumors. Green commented on them, saying: "There's been no decision on the future at all as far as I'm concerned. I'm planning on playing and seeing how things go...." In the fifth inning of the May 25, 2007, game against the
Florida Marlins, Green suffered a chip fracture of the
first metatarsal bone in his right foot when he fouled a ball off of it. Green at the time of the injury was batting .314, tenth-best in the NL, and .341 against right-handers, with five home runs, 22 RBIs, twelve doubles, and four stolen bases. On May 29, Green was placed on the 15-day
disabled list; his first time on the DL in his career. The bone was expected to fully heal in six weeks, but he was activated well before then; on June 11 he was back in the lineup, though the bone was not completely healed, and went 2–for–4 with a run batted in and a stolen base. On June 24, Green started at first base for the first time since 2006, when he was a member of the Diamondbacks.
Retirement After the 2007 season, Green became a free agent. He chose to retire before the start of the 2008 season as he wanted to be with his family. Green confirmed his retirement on February 28, 2008. Among all-time Jewish major league baseball players—through 2010—he was second in career home runs and RBIs (behind
Hank Greenberg), and tenth in batting average (behind
Morrie Arnovich).
Fielding In 1998, Green had 14 assists and five
double plays from the
outfield. Most of Green's
innings in the field were in
right field, where he was awarded a Gold Glove Award in 1999. Green received two votes (0.4%) and was eliminated from future
BBWAA voting. ==Team Israel==